The Silk Road or the Sea? Sasanian and Islamic Exports to Japan
Issue: Vol 3 No. 1 (2016)
Journal: Journal of Islamic Archaeology
This article considers the movement of commodities manufactured in southern Iraq during the Sasanian and Early Islamic periods to the furthest eastern extremity of the Old World: to the archipelago of Japan. In particular the focus is on two categories of non-perishable finds that survive within the archaeological record: glass vessels and turquoise blue alkaline glazed ceramic jars. We begin by providing an outline of the definition and dating of what is a commonplace and widely distributed ceramic product within the Middle East and western Indian Ocean area. It is then possible to place these finds within a broader context by reviewing the evidence for the earliest West Asian exports to Japan and what these might tell us about the mechanisms of their transmission and circulation and the role of such imports within an East Asian context. Specifically these include glass vessels dated to the Sasanian period followed some time later by ceramic vessels manufactured at the time of the Abbasid Caliphate. The continued arrival of Islamic glass into this later period is not a subject that will be covered specifically as it does not contribute directly to the main arguments that are developed below. Finally the finds are used to shed light on the broader debate surrounding the development of the Indian Ocean economy and to what extent Japan itself may have been commercially integrated within a wider commodity exchange network.
Author: Seth Priestman
1982. “Review of ‘Siraf III: the congregational mosque’ by D. Whitehouse.” Ars Orientalis 13: 188–189.
1975. “Wu Dai Min Guo Liu Hua Mu Fa Jue Bao Gao [Excavation Report on Liu Hua’s Tomb in Min State of the Five Dynasties Period].” Wenwu 1: 62–73.
1991. Fukuokashi Kōrokan Seki I. Hakkutsu Chousa Gaihō. Fukuokashi Maizou Bunkazai Chousa Hōkokusho 270: Fukuokashi Kyouiku Iinkai [Fukuoka City Kōrokan Site I. Excavation Research General Report. Fukuoka: Fukuoka City Archaeological Research Report 270, Fukuoka City Education Board].
1993. Dazaifu Shisei Dayori No. 510. Fukuoka ken Dazaifu shi Sōmubu Kikakuka: Fukuoka [Dazaifu City Government Journal No. 510. Fukuoka: Fukuoka Prefecture Dazaifu City General Affairs Department, Planning Section].
1995. Dazaifu Jōbōseki VII. Dazaifu shi Kyoiku Iinkai: Dazaifu shi no Bunkazai, dai 28 shu: Dazaifu [Dazaifu Jōbō Site VII. Dazaifu: Dazaifu City Education Board [Dazaifu City Archaeology 28].
2000. Dazaifu Jōbōseki XIV, ‘Ichinoue’ Shuhen no Chōsa. Dazaifu shi Kyouiku Iinkai [Dazaifu Jōbō Site XIV, Research Around ‘Ichinoue’. Dazaifu: Dazaifu City Board of Education.
2002. Christies Islamic Art and Manuscripts, Sale 6628, London October 15th. London: Christies.
2003. Christies Islamic Art and Manuscripts, Sale 6712, London April 29th. London: Christies.
2004. Kōrokan Seki 14. Fukuokashi Maizou Bukazai Chousa Hōkokusho 783: Fukuokashi Kyouiku Iinkai. [Kōrokan Site 14. Fukuoka: Fukuoka City Archaeological Research Report 783, Fukuoka City Education Board].
2006. Kōrokan Seki 16. Fukuokashi Maizou Bukazai Chousa Hōkokusho 875: Fukuokashi Kyouiku Iinkai. [Kōrokan Site 16. Fukuoka: Fukuoka City Archaeological Research Report 875, Fukuoka City Education Board].
2007a. Kodaino Hakata, Kōrokan to Sono Jidai. Kōrokan Seki Hakkutsu Niju Shūnen Kinen Tokubetsu Ten: Fukuokashi Hakubutsukan. [Ancient Hakata, Kōrokan and its Era. Special Exhibition Commemorating 20 years of Excavation at Kōrokan Site, Fukouka: Fukouka City Museum].
2007b. Hakozaki 28–Hakozaki Tochi Kukaku Seiri ni Tomonau Maizobunkazai Chōsa Hōkoku VI. Hakosaki Iseki dai 40–49 ji Chosa Hōkoku. Fukuoka shi Maizo Bunkazai Chōsa Hōkokusho 949 shu: Fukuoka shi Kyoiku iinkai [Hakozaki 28–Research Report VI. Effects on Archaeology Prompted by the New Hakozaki Land Divisions. Fukuoka: Hakozaki Site Nos. 40–49 Research Report, Fukuoka City Archaeological Research Report Compilation 949, Fukuoka City Board of Education].
2010. Dazaifu—Sono Eaiga to Kiseki. Kyūshū Rekishi Shiryokan Kinen Tokubetsu Ten: Kyūshū Rekishi Hakubutsukan. [History and Culture of Dazaifu. Special Exhibition Commemorating the Opening of Kyūshū Historical Museum, Kyūshū Historical Museum].
Batten, B. L.
2006. Gateway to Japan: Hakata in War and Peace, 500–1300. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
1993. “Pottery in Susa During the Seleucid, Parthian and Early Sasanian Periods.” In Materialien zur Archäologie der Seleukiden - und Partherzeit im südlichen Babylonien und im Golfgebiet, edited by U. Finkbeiner, 42–57. Tübingen: Deutches Archäologisches Institute Abteilung Baghdad.
1991. “The port of Mantai, Sri Lanka.” In Rome & India. The Ancient Sea Trade, edited by V. Begley and R. D. de Puma, 197–203. Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin.
2008. “Christianity in the Gulf during the first centuries of Islam.” Arabian Archaeology & Epigraphy 19: 71–108. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0471.2008.00293.x
1985. “Yang Zhou Chu Tu Gu Dai Bo Si You Tao Qi [Persian Glazed Pottery found in Yangzhou City].” Kaogu 2: 152–154.
1984. Manda. Excavations at an Island Port on the Kenyan Coast. Nairobi: British Institute in East Africa.
1995. “Turquoise Jars and Other West Asian Ceramics in China.” Bulletin of the Asia Institute 9: 19–39.
Cowell, M., and Z. Fukang.
2001. “Analysis and Source of the Cobalt-Blue Pigments Employed on Chinese Ceramics.” In Catalogue of Late Yuan and Ming Ceramics in the British Museum, edited by J. Harrison-Hall, 601–605. London: British Museum Press.
1975–1977. “Early Islamic pottery and China.” Transactions of the Oriental Ceramic Society 41: 263–275.
2003. “The Persian Gulf trade in late antiquity.” Journal of World History 14(1): 1–16. http://dx.doi.org/10.1353/jwh.2003.0005
1970. “Near Eastern wares under Chinese influence.” In Pottery and Metalworking in T’ang China. Their Chronology and External Relations, edited by W. Watson, 27–34. Colloquies on Art & Archaeology in Asia 1. London: Percival David Foundation of Chinese Art.
Fleming, S. J., R. G. V. Hancock, R. B. Mason, and R. E. Scott.
1992 “Tang polychrome wares: An interaction with the Islamic West.” In Proceedings of the International Symposium: Science and Technology of Ancient Ceramics, edited by Li Jiazhi and Chen Xianquo, 211–222. Shanghai: Shanghai Research Society of Science and Technology of Ancient Ceramics.
1972. “A fragment of a Sassanian cut glass bowl recently found at Kyoto.” In The Memorial Volume of the Vth International Congress on Iranian Art and Archaeology, Vol. II, Tehran–Isfahan–Shiraz 11th–18th April 1968, edited by M.Y. Kiani and A. Tajvidi, 306–312. Tehran.
1977. Persian Glass. Translated by E. B. Crawford, New York/Kyoto: Weatherhill/Tankosha.
2002. “West Asian Sassanian-Islamic ceramics in the Indian Ocean, South, Southeast and East Asia.” Man & Environment 27(1): 165–177.
1991. “Christian maritime trade of Sasanian Age in the Persian Gulf.” In Golf-Archäologie: Mesopotamien, Iran, Kuwait, Bahrain, Vereinigt Arabische Emirate und Oman, edited by K. Schippmann, A. Herling, and J.-F. Salles, 83–88. Leidorf: Internationale Archäologie 6.
2010. “Rare and strange goods. International trade in ninth-century Asia.” In Shipwrecked. Tang Treasures and Monsoon Winds, edited by R. Krahl, J. Guy, K. Wilson and J. Raby, 18–34. Singapore: Smithsonian Institution.
2000. “Trade and Innovation: The Rise of the Pottery Industry in Abbasid Basra.” Unpublished PhD thesis, Trinity College, University of Oxford.
1965. “‘Dusun jars’: From Mayfair and Friesland through Cairo to Sabah.” Sarawak Museum Journal 12: 69–74.
Hill, D. V., R. J. Speakman, and M. D. Glascock.
2004. “Chemical and mineralogical characterisation of Sasanian and Early Islamic glazed ceramics from the Deh Luran Plain, Southwest Iran.” Archaeometry 46(4): 585–605. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-4754.2004.00175.x
1973. “The Technical problems of copying Chinese porcelain in tin glaze.” Colloquies on Art and Archaeology in Asia 3: 79–87.
Hodges, R. and D. Whitehouse.
1983. Mohammed, Charlemagne and the Origins of Europe; Archaeology and the Pirenne Thesis. London: Duckworth.
Hourani, G. F.
1947. “Direct sailing between the Persian Gulf and China in pre-Islamic times.” Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Northern Ireland: 157–160.
1951. Arab Seafaring in the Indian Ocean in Ancient and Early Medieval Times. Expanded Edition (1995), edited by J. Carswell. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Horton, M. C.
1996. Shanga, the Archaeology of a Muslim Trading Community on the Coast of East Africa. Nairobi: Memoirs of the British Institute in Eastern Africa Memoir 14.
Horton, M. and S. Priestman.
Forthcoming. “Local and imported ceramics.” In Zanzibar’s Ancient Indian Ocean Trade and Contacts: Studies at Unguja Ukuu and Fukuchani edited by A. Crowther, N. Boivin and M. Horton.
1991. “Dated Islamic glass in China.” Bulletin of the Asia Institute 5 (New Series): 123–137.
2004. Unguja Ukuu on Zanzibar. An archaeological study of early urbanism. Uppsala: Studies in Global Archaeology 3.
2004. Sasanian and Islamic Pottery from Ras al-Khaimah: Classification Chronology and Analysis of Trade in the Western Indian Ocean. British Archaeological Reports International Series 1248/Society for Arabian Studies Monographs 1. Oxford: Archaeopress.
2007. “The decline of Eastern Arabia in the Sasanian period.” Arabian Archaeology & Epigraphy 18: 86–122. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0471.2007.00274.x
Khan, F. A.
1960. Banbhore. A Preliminary Report on the Recent Archaeological Excavations, 3rd Revised Edition (1969). Karachi: Department of Archaeology and Museums, Government of Pakistan.
1928. Les Céramiques Musulmanes de Suse au Musée du Louvre. Mémoires de la Délégation en Perse 19. Paris: Ernest Leroux.
2010. “Green wares from Southern China.” In Shipwrecked. Tang Treasures and Monsoon Winds, edited by R. Krahl, J. Guy, K. Wilson, and J. Raby, 184–200. Singapore: Smithsonian Institution.
1998. “From Ctesiphon to Nishapur: Studies in Islamic glass.” In The Art and Archaeology of Ancient Persia: New Light on the Parthian and Sasanian Empires, edited by V. S. Curtis, R. Hillenbrand, and J. M Rogers, 133–140. London: IB Tauris.
Laing, E. J.
1991. “A Report on western Asian glassware in the Far East.” Bulletin of the Asia Institute 5 (New Series): 109–121.
1947. Early Islamic Pottery: Mesopotamia, Egypt, and Persia. London: Faber & Faber.
Mason, R.B. and E.J. Keall.
1991. “The ʿAbbāsid glazed wares of Sīrāf and the Basra connection: Petrographic analysis.” Iran 29: 51–66.
1972. “On the painted Sassanian glass receptacle found in Japan.” In The Memorial Volume of the Vth International Congress on Iranian Art and Archaeology, Vol. II. Tehran–Isfahan–Shiraz 11th–18th April 1968, edited by M.Y. Kiani, and A. Tajvidi, 353–356. Tehran.
1968. “The relationship between Persian and Chinese ceramics in medieval Iran.” In The Memorial Volume of the Vth International Congress on Iranian Art and Archaeology, Vol. II. Tehran–Isfahan–Shiraz 11th–18th April 1968, edited by M.Y. Kiani, and A. Tajvidi, 360–361. Tehran.
2010. Tokubetsuten Haijonokita: Kuni-kyō–Kizugawa Ryoiki no Nara Jidai. Kyotofu Tateyamajo Kyodo Shiryokan [Special Exhibition Northern Capital of Nara: Kuni-kyō–the region of Kizu River from the Nara Period. Kyoto: Kyoto Prefecture Tateyama Castle Archival Centre].
Morony, M. G.
2001–2002. “The late Sasanian economic impact on the Arabian Peninsula.” Nāme-ye Irān-e Bāstān (International Journal of Ancient Iranian Studies) 1:2: 25–37.
2011. Mariners and Merchants: A Study of the Ceramics from Sanjan (Gujarat). British Archaeological Reports S2231/Sanjan Reports Volume 1. Oxford: Archaeopress.
2009. ‘Toki o kakeru Shirukurōdo Iki’, Tabisuru Nagasakigaku–Umi no Michi–(I) Iki: Yamataikoku eno Michi. Kaijono ōkoku Tabibito no Kōsaten, Vol. 11. Nagasakiken Bunka Shinkoka [‘Travelling Across Time: Silk Road to Iki’, Travelling Nagasaki Study–The Sea Route–(I) Iki Island: Road to Yamataikoku. The Kingdom of the Sea, the Travellers’ Crossroad, Vol 11. Nagasaki: Nagasaki Prefecture Culture Promotion Department].
2011. Higashi Ajia no Kuretato - Iki Jima. Kyushu Rekishi Shiryokan Kenkyu ronshu 36, Nisenjuichi nen San gatsu [From Crete to Iki Island. Kyushu Historical Archival Research Papers 36, March 2011].
Patitucci, S. and G. Uggeri.
1984. Failakah Insediamenti Medievali Islamici. Ricerche e Scavi nel Kuwait. Rome: L’Erma di Bretschneider.
Phillipson, D. W.
2000. Archaeology at Aksum, Ethiopia, 1993–7. London: Memoirs of the British Institute in Eastern Africa 17.
Piacentini, V. F.
1985. “Ardashīr i Pāpakān and the Wares Against the Arabs: Working Hypothesis on the Sasanian Hold of the Gulf.” Proceedings of the Society for Arabian Studies 15: 57–77.
Pope, A. U., and P. Ackerman.
1938. A Survey of Persian Art. From Prehistoric Times to the Present, Vol. IV. London/New York: Oxford University Press.
2005a. “Settlement and Ceramics in the Southern Iran: An Analysis of the Sasanian and Islamic Periods in the Williamson Collection.” Durham: Unpublished M.A. Thesis, Department of Archaeology, Durham University.
2005b. “The rise of Siraf: Long-term development of trade emporia within the Persian Gulf.” In Proceedings of the International Congress of Siraf Port, November 14–16, 2005, Bushehr, 137—156. Bushehr: Bushehr Branch of Iranology Foundation and Bushehr University of Medical Sciences.
2011. “Opaque glazed wares: Definition, dating and distribution of a key Iraqi ceramic export in the Abbasid period.” Iran 49: 89–114.
2013. “A Quantitative Archaeological Analysis of Ceramic Exchange in the Persian Gulf and Western Indian Ocean, AD c.400–1275.” Unpublished PhD thesis, Centre for Maritime Archaeology, University of Southampton.
In Press. “Bushehr, Dashtestan and Siraf: The transformation of the Sasanian maritime trade network in the upper Persian Gulf.” In New Studies in Sasanian Archaeology: Economy, Industry and Material Culture, edited by St J. Simpson. London: British Museum Press.
Forthcoming. Siraf: Excavated finds in the British Museum. British Institute of Persian Studies Archaeological Monograph Series. Oxford: Oxbow.
Priestman, S. and D. Kennet.
Forthcoming The Williamson Collection Project: Regional Economic Development of Sasanian and Islamic Southern Iran. British Institute of Persian Studies Archaeological Monograph Series. Oxford: Oxbow.
Priestman, S. and St J. Simpson, eds.
Rawson, J., M. S. Tite, and M. J. Hughes.
1987–1988. “The Export of Tang Sancai Wares: Some Recent Researches.” Transaction of the Oriental Ceramic Society 52: 39–62.
1995. “1994 Excavations at Jazirat al-Hulayla, Ras al-Khaimah.” Bulletin of Archaeology, The University of Kanazawa 22: 1–74.
Sasaki, T., and H. Sasaki.
1996. “1995 Excavations at Jazirat al-Hulayla, Ras al-Khaimah.” Bulletin of Archaeology, The University of Kanazawa 23: 37–178.
1998. “1997 Excavations at Jazirat al-Hulayla, Ras al-Khaimah, U.A.E.” Bulletin of Archaeology, The University of Kanazawa 24: 99–196.
2000. “1998 Excavations at Jazirat al-Hulayla.” Bulletin of Archaeology, The University of Kanazawa 25: 118–169.
2011. “Nara Shutsudo Aomidori Yūtōkibin no Sanchi, Ryūtsū, Rūto, Yōtō, Naiyobutsu, Kachi [The Origin, Circulation, Route, Use, Content and Value of Blue-Green Glazed Pottery Excavated in Nara].” Bulletin of Archaeology the University of Kanazawa 32: 13–17.
Sedov, A. V.
2007. “The port of Qanaʾ and the incense trade.” In Food for the Gods. New Light on the Ancient Incense Trade, edited by D. P. S. Peacock and D. Williams, 71–111. Oxford: Oxbow.
Simpson, St. J.
2007. “From San Marco to South Arabia: Observations on Sasanian cut glass.” In Facts and Artefact: Arts in the Islamic World, edited by A. Hagedorn, and A. Shalem, 59–88, Festschrift for Jens Kröger on his 65th Birthday. Leiden: Brill.
In Press “Christians on Iraq’s Desert Frontier.” Al-Rafidan.
2007. “Rome and Mesopotamia–importers into India in the first millennium AD.” Antiquity 81: 972–988. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0003598X00096058
1970. “On T’ang soft-glazed pottery.” In Pottery and Metalworking in T’ang China. Their Chronology and External Relations, edited by W. Watson, 41–47. Colloquies on Art and Archaeology in Asia 1. London: Percival David Foundation of Chinese Art.
1968. “Excavations at Siraf: First interim report.” Iran 6: 1–22.
1970. “Excavations at Siraf: Third interim report.” Iran 8: 1–18.
1971. “Excavations at Siraf: Fourth interim report.” Iran 9: 1–17.
1972. “Excavations at Siraf: Fifth interim report.” Iran 10: 63–87.
1973. “Chinese stoneware from Siraf: The earliest finds.” In South Asian Archaeology. Papers from the First International Conference of South Asian Archaeologists in Western Europe, edited by N. Hammond, 241–255. Cambridge: Duckworth.
1979. “Islamic glazed pottery in Iraq and the Persian Gulf: The Ninth and Tenth Centuries.” Annali, Instituto Orientale di Napoli 39: 45–61.
1996. “Sasanian Maritime Trade.” In The Indian Ocean in Antiquity, edited by J. Reade, 339–349. London/New York: Kegan Paul International.
2005. Sasanian and Post-Sasanian Glass in the Corning Museum of Glass. New York: Corning.
Whitehouse, D., and A.G. Williamson.
1973. “Sasanian maritime trade.” Iran 11: 29–49.
Williamson, A. G.
1972. “Persian Gulf commerce in the Sasanian period and the first two centuries of Islam.” Bastan Chenasi va Honar-e Iran 9/10: 97–109 (foreign section), 142–151 (Iranian section).
Wood, N., M. Tite, C. Doherty, and B. Gilmour.
2007. “A technological examination of 9th–10th Century AD Abbasid Blue-and-White Ware from Iraq, and its comparison with 8th century AD Chinese Blue-and-White Sancai Ware.” Archaeometry 49(4): 665–684. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-4754.2007.00327.x
Wood, N. and M. Tite.
2009. “Blue and White–the early years: Tang China and Abbasid Iraq compared.” In Transfer: The Influence of China on World Ceramics, edited by S. Pierson, 21–45. Colloquies on the Art and Archaeology in Asia 24. London: Percival David Foundation of Chinese Art.
Wood, N., C. Doherty and M. Rosser-Owen.
2009. “A technological study of Iraqi copies of Chinese Changsha and Chinese Sancai wares found at Samarra–together with some Chinese originals.” Gu Taoci Kexue Jishu 8: 154–180.
1986. “Persian and Korean ceramics unearthed in China.” Orientations 17(5): 47–53.
1994. “Shifts in the use of Zhejiang Green Glazed wares at Dazaifu between the late eighth and fourteenth centuries.” In New Light on Chinese Yue and Longquan Wares. Archaeological Ceramics Found in Eastern and Southern Asia, A.D. 800–1400, edited by Chuimei Ho, 169–186. Hong Kong: Centre of Asian Studies Occasional Monograph 110.