Item Details

Fusing the Horizons, or Why Context Matters: The Interdependence of Fieldwork and Museum Study in Mediterranean Archaeology

Issue: Vol 29 No. 2 (2016)

Journal: Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology

Subject Areas: Ancient History Archaeology

DOI: 10.1558/jmea.v29i2.32574

Abstract:

In a recent JMA article (JMA 28.2, December 2015), Robin Osborne argued that Mediterranean archaeology places too much emphasis on fieldwork and too little on museum study. In doing so he has set up an antithesis between two kinds of archaeological practice: the former ‘in the field’, undertaken chiefly by specialists in prehistory, and the latter in the museum, undertaken principally by Classical archaeologists who are also experts in the traditional subjects of sculpture and vase painting. I argue that this antithesis is at best misleading, and a poor guide to how best to turn material evidence into historical knowledge. These issues are explored in relation to a set of case studies where recent survey and fieldwork have shed light on old ‘museum’ material, and where a reappraisal of that material has in turn affected research design in the field as well as historical interpretation. This study concentrates on the results of a number of fieldwork projects (both excavation and survey) covering Archaic and Classical material in eastern Crete, with a particular focus on first on pithoi (storage jars) found in the excavation of houses and then terracotta plaques from various sanctuary deposits. New fieldwork, conducted to modern standards, when combined with a reappraisal of older ‘museum’ material can, when conducted using a range of both new and traditional methods, yield new insights. This combination can offer a true ‘fusion of horizons’, in Gadamer’s (1975) sense.

Author: James Whitley, Robin Osbourne

View Original Web Page

References :

Ancient Sources
Ephoros (in Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker
no. 70, usually abbreviated to FrGrHist = F.
Jacoby (ed.) 1926, Die Fragmente der griechischen
Historiker: Zweiter Teil: Zeitgeschichte A: Universalgeschichte
und Hellenika nr. 64-105. Berlin:
Weidsmannsche Buchhandlung.
Strabo, Geography.
References
Appadurai, A.
1986a Introduction: commodities and the politics of
value. In A. Appadurai (ed.), The Social Life of
Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective, 3-63.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511819582.003
1986b (ed.) The Social Life of Things: Commodities in
Cultural Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Arrington, N.T., D. Terzopoulou, M. Tasaklaki, M.L.
Lawall, D.J. Brellas and C.E. White
2016 Molyvoti, Thrace, archaeological project: 2013
preliminary report. Hesperia 85: 1-64. http://
dx.doi.org/10.2972/hesperia.85.1.0001
Beazley, J.D.
1963 Attic Red-Figure Vase Painters. 2nd edition.
Oxford: Clarendon.
Beard, M.
2001 ‘Pausanias in petticoats’, or the Blue Jane. In
S.E. Alcock, J.F. Cherry and J. Elsner (eds.),
Pausanias: Travel and Memory in Roman Greece,
224-39. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Boardman, J.
1961 The Cretan Collection in Oxford: The Dictaean
Cave and Iron Age Crete. Oxford: Clarendon.
1975 Athenian Red Figure Vases: The Archaic Period.
London: Thames and Hudson.
Bosanquet, R.C.
1902 Excavations at Praesos, I. Annual of the British
School at Athens 8: 231-70. http://dx.doi.
org/10.1017/S0068245400001453
Brisart, T.
2007 L’atelier de pithoi à reliefs d’Aphrati: les fragments
du musée Bénaki. Bulletin de correspondance
hellénique 131: 95-137.
Broodbank, C.
2013 The Making of the Middle Sea: A History of the
Mediterranean from the Beginning to the Emergence
of the Classical World. London: Thames
and Hudson.
Brun, H., and A. Duplouy
2014 Le sanctuaire de Déméter à Vamiès (Itanos,
Crète orientale): topographie, architecture et
petite plastique de terre cuite. Bulletin de correspondance
hellénique 138: 201-44.
Cahill, N.
2002 Household and City Organization at Olynthus. New
Haven, Connecticut: Yale University Press. http://
dx.doi.org/10.12987/yale/9780300084955.
001.0001
Cuno, J.
2008 Who Owns Antiquity? Museums and the Battle
over our Ancient Heritage. Princeton, New Jersey:
Princeton University Press.
Dawkins, R.M. (ed.)
1929 The Sanctuary of Artemis Orthia at Sparta. Journal
of Hellenic Studies Supplement 5. London:
Macmillan.
de Polignac, F.
1984 La Naissance de la cité grecque. Paris: Editions La
Découverte.
Dohan, E.H.
1931 Archaic Cretan terracottas in America. Metropolitan
Museum Studies 3: 209-28. http://dx.doi.
org/10.2307/1522780
Ebbinghaus, S.
2005 Protector of the city, or the art of storage in Early
Greece. Journal of Hellenic Studies 125: 51-72.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0075426900007102
Eidinow, E., J. Kindt and R. Osborne (eds.)
2016 Theologies of Ancient Greek Religion. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Erickson, B.L.
2009 Roussa Ekklesia, part I: religion and politics
in East Crete. American Journal of Archaeology
113: 353-404. http://dx.doi.org/10.3764/
aja.113.3.353
2010 Crete in Transition: Pottery Styles and Island History
in the Archaic and Classical Periods. Hesperia
Supplement 45. Princeton, New Jersey: American
School of Classical Studies at Athens.
Fehr, B.
1970 Kretische Pinakes und Protomen. In L.L. Möller
(ed.), Dädalische Kunst auf Kreta im 7. Jahrhundert
v. Chr, 94-105. Mainz: Philipp von Zabern.
Forster, E.S.
1902 Praesos: the terracottas. Annual of the British
School at Athens 8 [1901-1902]: 271-81. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0068245400001465
1905 Terracotta plaques from Praesos. Annual of the
British School at Athens 11 [1904-1905]: 243-57.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0068245400002598
Frielinghaus, H.
2011 Die Helme von Olympia: Ein Beitrag zu Waffenweihungen
in griechischen Heiligtürmen. Olympische
Forschungen 33. Berlin and New York:
Walter de Gruyter.
Gadamer, H.G.
1975 Truth and Method. London: Sheed and Ward.
Gagarin, M., and P. Perlman
2016 The Laws of Ancient Crete c.650-400 BCE.
Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Galanaki, K.E., C. Papadaki and K.S. Christakis
2015 The Hellenistic settlement on Prophetes Ilias
at Arkalochori, Crete: preliminary remarks. In
D.C. Haggis and C.M. Antonaccio (eds.), Classical
Archaeology in Context: Theory and Practice
in Excavation in the Greek World, 315-32.
Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter. http://dx.doi.
org/10.1515/9781934078471-014
Haggis, D.C.
2014 Azoria and Archaic urbanization. In F. Gaignerot-
Driessen and J. Driessen (eds), Cretan
Cities: Formation and Transformation. Aegis
actes de colloque 7: 119-39. Louvain-la-Neuve:
Presses Universitaires de Louvain.
2015 The archaeology of urbanization: research design
and the excavation of an Archaic Greek city on
Crete. In D.C. Haggis and C.M. Antonaccio
(eds.), Classical Archaeology in Context: Theory
and Practice in Excavation in the Greek World,
219-58. Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1515/9781934078471-012
Haggis, D.C., and C.M. Antonaccio
2015a A contextual archaeology of Ancient Greece.
In D.C. Haggis and C.M. Antonaccio (eds),
Classical Archaeology in Context: Theory and
Practice in Excavation in the Greek World, 1-20.
Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter. http://dx.doi.
org/10.1515/9781934078471-004
2015b (eds) Classical Archaeology in Context: Theory
and Practice in Excavation in the Greek World.
Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter.
Halbherr, F.
1901 Cretan expedition XVI: report on the researches
at Praesos. American Journal of Archaeology 5:
371-92. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/496581
Henderson, J.
2001 Farnell’s Cults: the making and breaking of
Pausanias in Victorian archaeology and anthropology.
In S.E. Alcock, J.F. Cherry and J. Elsner
(eds.), Pausanias: Travel and Memory in Roman
Greece, 207-23. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
Higgins, R.A.
1954 Catalogue of the Terracottas in the Department of
Greek and Roman Antiquities, British Museum. 2
volumes. London: British Museum.
Hodder, I.
2011 Human-thing entanglement: towards an integrated
archaeological perspective. Journal of the
Royal Anthropological Institute 17: 154-77. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9655.2010.01674.x
Horden, P., and N. Purcell
2000 The Corrupting Sea: A Study of Mediterranean
History. Oxford: Blackwell.
Kersel, M.
2015 Storage wars: solving the archaeological curation
crisis. Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology
and Heritage Studies 3: 42-54. http://dx.doi.
org/10.5325/jeasmedarcherstu.3.1.0042
Kopytoff, I.
1986 The cultural biography of things. In A. Appadurai
(ed.), The Social Life of Things: Commodities
in Cultural Perspective, 64-91. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Kyriakou, A., and A. Tourtas
2015 Detecting patterns through context analysis:
a case study of deposits from the sanctuary
of Eukleia at Aegae (Vergina). In D.C.
Haggis and C.M. Antonaccio (eds.), Classical
Archaeology in Context: Theory and Practice in
Excavation in the Greek World, 357-84. Berlin
and Boston: De Gruyter. http://dx.doi.
org/10.1515/9781934078471-016
Lebessi, A.
1985 Το Ιερό του Ερμή και της Αφροδίτης στη
Σύμη Βιάννου I. Χάλκινα Κρητικά Τορεύματα.
Βιβλιοθήκη της εν Αθήναις Αρχαιολογικής
Εταιρείας 102. Athens: Archaeological Society
of Athens.
Lissarrague, F.
1990 The Aesthetics of the Greek Banquet: Images
of Wine and Ritual. Translated by Andrew
Szegedy-Maszak. Princeton, New Jersey:
Princeton University Press. http://dx.doi.
org/10.1515/9781400861156
Lynch, K.
2011 The Symposium in Context: Pottery from a Late
Archaic House near the Athenian Agora. Hesperia
Supplement 46. Princeton, New Jersey: American
School of Classical Studies at Athens.
2014 Fine ware pottery from a late Archaic house
near the Athenian Agora. Mètis (new series) 12:
81-98.
Madgwick, R., and J. Whitley
In press Consuming the wild: more thoughts on the
andreion. In J. Blok, F. van den Eijnde and R.
Strootman (eds), Feasting and Polis Institutions.
Leiden: Brill.
Margaritis, E.
2015 Cultivating classical archaeology: agricultural
activities, use of space and occupation patterns
in Hellenistic Greece. In D.C. Haggis
and C.M. Antonaccio (eds.), Classical
Archaeology in Context: Theory and Practice in
Excavation in the Greek World, 332-54. Berlin
and Boston: De Gruyter. http://dx.doi.
org/10.1515/9781934078471-015
Mollard-Besques, S.
1954 Catalogue raisonné des figurines et reliefs en terre
cuite grecs, étrusques et romains I. Époques préhellénique,
géométrique et archaïque. Paris: Editions
des Musées Nationaux.
Nevett, L.
1999 House and Society in the Ancient Greek World.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Nicholls, R.V.
1952 Type, group and series: a re-consideration of
some coroplastic fundamentals. Annual of the
British School at Athens 47: 217-26. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0068245400012351
Osborne, R.
2001 Why did Athenian pots appeal to the Etruscans?
World Archaeology 33: 277-95. http://dx.doi.
org/10.1080/00438240120079299
2011 The History Written on the Classical Greek Body.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
2014 Afterword: towards an understanding of the
choices made by the producers and consumers
of Attic pottery. Mètis (new series) 12: 189-98.
2015 De-contextualising and re-contextualising: why
Mediterranean archaeology needs to get out of
the trench and back into the museum. Journal of
Mediterranean Archaeology 28: 241-61. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1558/jmea.v28i2.29533
Parker, R.
2011 On Greek Religion. Townsend Lectures/Cornell
Studies in Classical Philology 60. Ithaca, New
York: Cornell University Press.
Perlman, P.J.
2004 Crete. In M.H. Hansen and T.H. Nielsen (eds.),
An Inventory of Archaic and Classical Poleis: An
Investigation Conducted by the Copenhagen Polis
Centre for the Danish National Research Foundation:
1144-95. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pilz, O.
2011 Frühe matrizengeformte Terrakoten auf Kreta:
Votivpraxis und Gesellschaftsstruktur in spätgeometrischer
und früharchaischer Zeit. Beiträge zur
Archäologie Griechenlands 2. Mohnsee: Bibliopolis.
2014 Narrative art in Archaic Crete. In O. Pilz and G.
Seelentag (eds.), Cultural Practices and Material
Culture in Archaic and Classical Crete, 243-61.
Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter. http://dx.doi.
org/10.1515/9783110331783.243
Pilz, O., and G. Seelentag (eds.)
2014 Cultural Practices and Material Culture in
Archaic and Classical Crete. Berlin and Boston:
De Gruyter.
Prent, M.
2005 Cretan Sanctuaries and Cults: Continuity and
Change from Late Minoan IIIC to the Archaic
Period. Religions in the Graeco-Roman World
154. Leiden: Brill. http://dx.doi.org/10.1163/
9789047406907
Price, S.
1989 Primitive Art in Civilized Places. Chicago: University
of Chicago Press.
Reusser, C.
2002 Vasen für Etrurien: Verbreitung und Funktionen
attischer Keramik im Etrurien des 6. und 5. Jahrhunderts
vor Christus. Zürich: Akanthus.
Rhodes, P.J.
1991 The Athenian code of laws, 410-399 B.C.
Journal of Hellenic Studies 111: 87-100. http://
dx.doi.org/10.2307/631889
Romano, D.G., M.E. Voyatzis, A. Sarris, G.H. Davis, S.B.
Mentzer, E. Margaritis, E. and B.M. Starkovich
2014 The Mt Lykaion excavation and survey project,
part 1: the Upper Sanctuary. Hesperia 83: 569-
652.
Seelentag, G.
2015 Das Archaische Kreta: Institutionalisierung im
frühen Griechenland. Klio Beihefte Neue Folge
24. Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1515/9783110368468
Vlassopoulos, K.
2007 Unthinking the Greek Polis: Ancient Greek History
Beyond Eurocentrism. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/
CBO9780511482946
Vogeikoff-Brogan, N.
2011 Domestic assemblages from Trypetos, Siteia:
private and communal aspects. In K. Glowacki
and N. Vogeikoff-Brogan (eds.), STEGA: The
Archaeology of Houses and Households in Ancient
Crete. Hesperia Supplement 44: 409-30. Princeton,
New Jersey: American School of Classical
Studies at Athens.
Von Bothmer, D.
1976 Der Euphronioskrater in New York. Archäologischer
Anzeiger 1976: 485-512.
Watson, P., and C. Todeschini
2006 The Medici Conspiracy: The Illicit Journey of
Looted Antiquities, From Italy’s Tomb Raiders to
the World’s Greatest Museums. New York: Public
Affairs Books.
Westgate, R.
2007 House and society in Classical and Hellenistic
Crete: a case study in regional variation. American
Journal of Archaeology 111: 423-57. http://
dx.doi.org/10.3764/aja.111.3.423
Westgate, R., N. Fisher and J. Whitley (eds.)
2007 Building Communities: House, Settlement and
Society in the Aegean and Beyond. British School
at Athens Studies 15. London: British School at
Athens.
Whitley, J.
2008 Identity and sacred topography: the sanctuaries
of Praisos in Eastern Crete. In A. Holm
Rasmussen and S. William Rasmussen (eds.),
Religion and Society: Rituals, Resources and
Identity in the Ancient Graeco-Roman World:
The BOMOS Conferences 2002-2005. Analecta
Romana Instituti Danici Supplementum 40:
233-46. Rome: Edizioni Quasar.
2011 Praisos V: a preliminary report on the 2007
excavation season. Annual of the British School
at Athens 106: 3-45. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/
S0068245411000013
2012 Agency in Greek art. In T.J. Smith and D.
Plantzos (eds.), A Companion to Greek Art, 579-
95. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell. http://dx.doi.
org/10.1002/9781118273289.ch30
2014 Commensality and the ‘Citizen State’: the case of
Praisos. In F. Gaignerot-Driessen and J. Driessen
(eds.), Cretan Cities: Formation and Transformation.
Aegis actes de colloque 7: 141-63. Louvainla-
Neuve: Presses Universitaires de Louvain.
2015 Scholarly traditions and scientific paradigms:
method and reflexivity in the study of ancient
Praisos. In D.C. Haggis and C.M. Antonaccio
(eds.), Classical Archaeology in Context: Theory
and Practice in Excavation in the Greek World,
23-49. Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1515/9781934078471-005
In press The krater and the pithos: two kinds of agency.
In L. Nevett and J. Whitley (eds.), An Age of
Experiment: Classical Archaeology Transformed
1976-2014. Cambridge: McDonald Institute
for Archaeological Research.
Zographaki, V., and A. Farnoux
2011 Mission franco-hellénique de Dréros. Bulletin
de correspondance hellénique 135: 625-46.