Item Details

Advancing the Cognitive Science of Religion through Replication and Open Science


Journal: Journal for the Cognitive Science of Religion

Subject Areas: Religious Studies Cognitive Studies Linguistics

DOI: 10.1558/jcsr.39039


The Cognitive Science of Religion (CSR) is a relatively young but prolific field that has offered compelling insights into religious minds and practices. However, many empirical findings within this field are still preliminary and their reliability remains to be determined. In this paper, we first argue that it is crucial to critically evaluate the CSR literature and adopt open science practices and replication research in particular to move the field forward. Second, we highlight the outcomes of previous replications and make suggestions for future replication studies in the CSR, with a particular focus on neuroscience, developmental psychology, and qualitative research. Finally, we provide a "replication script" with advice on how to select, conduct, and organize replication research. Our approach is illustrated with a "glimpse behind the scenes" of the recently launched Cross-Cultural Religious Replication Project, in the hope of inspiring scholars of religion to embrace open science and replication in their own research.


Author: Suzanne Hoogeveen, Michiel van Elk

View Original Web Page

References :

Anczyk, A., H. Grzymala-Moszczyńska, A. Krzysztof-Swiderska and J. Prusak. 2019. "The Replication Crisis and Qualitative Research in the Psychology of Religion." The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 29: 278-291. 1080/10508619.2019.1687197

Anderson, M. S., B. C. Martinson and R. De Vries. 2007. "Normative Dissonance in Science: Results from a National Survey of U.S. Scientists." Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics 2: 3-14.

Baker, M. 2016. "Is There a Reproducibility Crisis?" Nature 533: 452-454.

Bakker, M., C. H. J. Hartgerink, J. M. Wicherts and H. L. J. van der Maas. 2016. "Researchers' Intuitions about Power in Psychological Research." Psychological Science 27: 1069-1077.

Banerjee, K. and P. Bloom. 2013. "Would Tarzan Believe in God? Conditions for the Emergence of Religious Belief." Trends in Cognitive Sciences 17: 7-8. 1016/j.tics.2012.11.005

Barch, D. M. and T. Yarkoni. 2013. "Introduction to the Special Issue on Reliability and Replication in Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience Research." Cognitive, Affective, and Behavioral Neuroscience 13: 687-689.

Barrett, J. L. 1998. "Cognitive Constraints on Hindu Concepts of the Divine." Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 37(4): 608-619.

----. 2000. "Exploring the Natural Foundations of Religion." Trends in Cognitive Sciences 4: 29-34.

----. 2018. "Some Common Misunderstandings about Cognitive Approaches to the Study of Religion: A Reply to Sterelny." Religion, Brain & Behavior 8: 425-428. https: //

Barrett, J. L., R. M. Newman and R. Richert. 2003. "When Seeing Is Not Believing: Children's Understanding of Humans' and Non-Humans' Use of Background Knowledge in Interpreting Visual Displays." Journal of Cognition and Culture 3: 91-108. https: //

Barrett, J. L., R. A. Richert and A. Driesenga. 2001. "God's Beliefs Versus Mother's: The Development of Nonhuman Agent Concepts." Child Development 72: 50-65. https: //

Bem, D. J. 2011. "Feeling the Future: Experimental Evidence for Anomalous Retroactive Influences on Cognition and Affect." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 100: 407-425.

Bering, J. M. 2006. "The Folk Psychology of Souls." Behavioral and Brain Sciences 29: 453- 462.

Bishop, L. 2009. "Ethical Sharing and Reuse of Qualitative Data." Australian Journal of Social Issues 44: 255-272.

Bloom, P. 2005. Descartes' Baby: How the Science of Child Development Explains What Makes Us Human. New York: Random House.

----. 2007. "Religion Is Natural." Developmental Science 10: 147-151. 10.1111/j.1467-7687.2007.00577.x

Boekel, W., E. Wagenmakers, L. Belay, A. J. Verhagen, S. D. Brown and B. Forstmann. 2015. "A Purely Confirmatory Replication Study of Structural Brain-Behavior Correlations." Cortex 66: 115-133.

Bonett, D. G. 2012. "Replication-Extension Studies." Current Directions in Psychological Science 21: 409-412.

Botvinik-Nezer, R., F. Holzmeister, C. F. Camerer, A. Dreber, J. Huber, M. Johannesson, M. Kirchler, R. Iwanir, J. A. Mumford, R. A. Adcock, P. Avesani, B. M. Baczkowski, A. Bajracharya, L. Bakst, S. Ball, M. Barilari, N. Bault, D. Beaton, J. Beitner ... T. Schonberg. 2020. "Variability in the Analysis of a Single Neuroimaging Dataset by Many Teams." Nature 582: 84-88.

Botvinik-Nezer, R., R. Iwanir, F. Holzmeister, J. Huber, M. Johannesson, M. Kirchler, A. Dreber, C. F. Camerer, R. A. Poldrack and T. Schonberg. 2019. "fMRI Data of Mixed Gambles from the Neuroimaging Analysis Replication and Prediction Study." Scientific Data 6: 106.

Bulbulia, J. 2013. "The Arts Transform the Cognitive Science of Religion." Journal for the Cognitive Science of Religion 1(2): 141-160.

Bulbulia, J. and E. Slingerland. 2012. "Religious Studies as a Life Science." Numen. International Review for the History of Religions 59: 564-613. 1163/15685276-12341240

Button, K. S., J. P. A. Ioannidis, C. Mokrysz, B. A. Nosek, J. Flint, E. S. J. Robinson and M. R. Munafò. 2013. "Power Failure: Why Small Sample Size Undermines the Reliability of Neuroscience." Nature Reviews Neuroscience 14: 365-376. https://doi. org/10.1038/nrn3475

Camerer, C. F., A. Dreber, F. Holzmeister, T. Ho, J. Huber, M. Johannesson, M. Kirchler, G. Nave, B. Nosek, T. Pfeiffer, A. Altmejd, N. Buttrick, T. Chan, Y. Chen, E. Forsell, E. Heikensten, L. Hummer, T. Imai, S. Isaksson ... H. Wu. 2018. "Evaluating Replicability of Social Science Experiments in Nature and Science." Nature Human Behaviour 2: 637-644.

Camerer, C. F., A. Dreber, T.-H. Ho, J. Huber, M. Johannesson, M. Kirchler, J. Almenberg, A. Altmejd, T. Chan, E. Heikensten, F. Holzmeister, T. Imai, S. Isaksson, G. Nave, T. Pfeiffer and M. Razen. 2016. "Evaluating Replicability of Laboratory Experiments in Economics." Science 351: 1433-1436.

Cesario, J. 2014. "Priming, Replication, and the Hardest Science." Perspectives on Psychological Science 9: 40-48.

Chambers, C. D. 2013. "Registered Reports: A New Publishing Initiative at Cortex." Cortex 49: 609-610.

Charles, S. J., J. E. Bartlett, K. J. Messick, T. J. Coleman III and A. Uzdavines. 2019. "Researcher Degrees of Freedom in the Psychology of Religion." The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 29: 230-245.

Chartier, C., M. Kline, R. McCarthy, M. Nuijten, D. J. Dunleavy and A. Ledgerwood. 2018. "The Cooperative Revolution Is Making Psychological Science Better." APS Observer (30 November).

Chatard, A., G. Hirschberger and T. Pyszczynski. 2020. "A Word of Caution about Many Labs 4: If You Fail to Follow Your Preregistered Plan, You May Fail to Find a Real Effect." (Preprint). PsyArXiv.

Claesen, A., S. L. B. T. Gomes, F. Tuerlinckx and W. Vanpaemel. 2019. "Preregistration: Comparing Dream to Reality." PsyArXiv.

Consortium, T. M. 2020. "Quantifying Sources of Variability in Infancy Research Using the Infant-Directed-Speech Preference." Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Science 3(1): 24-52.

Corriveau, K. H., E. E. Chen and P. L. Harris. 2015. "Judgments about Fact and Fiction by Children from Religious and Nonreligious Backgrounds." Cognitive Science 39: 353-382.

Cova, F., B. Strickland, A. Abatista, A. Allard, J. Andow, M. Attie, J. Beebe, R. Berniūnas, J. Boudesseul, M. Colombo, F. Cushman, R. Diaz, N'D. N. van Dongen, V. Dranseika, B. D. Earp, A. G. Torres, I. Hannikainen, J. V. HernándezConde, W. Hu ... X. Zhou. 2018. "Estimating the Reproducibility of Experimental Philosophy." Review of Philosophy and Psychology (14 June): 1-36. 1007/s13164-018-0400-9

Cristia, A., A. Seidl, L. Singh and D. Houston. 2016. "Test-Retest Reliability in Infant Speech Perception Tasks." Infancy 21: 648-667.

Crüwell, S., J. van Doorn, A. Etz, M. C. Makel, H. Moshontz, J. C. Niebaum, A. Orben, S. Parsons and M. Schulte-Mecklenbeck. 2019. "Seven Easy Steps to Open Science." Zeitschrift für Psychologie 227: 237-248. a000387

de Rijcke, S. and B. Penders. 2018. "Resist Calls for Replicability in the Humanities." Nature 560: 29.

DeHaven, A. C. 2017. Preregistration: A Plan, Not a Prison. (23 May). Center for Open Science.

Dienes, Z. 2014. "Using Bayes to Get the Most Out of Non-Significant Results." Frontiers in Psychology 5: 781 (1-17).

Doyen, S., O. Klein, C. L. Pichon and A. Cleeremans. 2012. "Behavioral Priming: It's All in the Mind, but Whose Mind?" PLoS ONE 7(1): 1-7. e29081. pone.0029081

Dreber, A., T. Pfeiffer, J. Almenberg, S. Isaksson, B. Wilson, Y. Chen, B. A. Nosek and M. Johannesson. 2015. "Using Prediction Markets to Estimate the Reproducibility of Scientific Research." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 112: 15343-15347.

Dubois, J. and R. Adolphs. 2016. "Building a Science of Individual Differences from fMRI." Trends in Cognitive Sciences 20: 425-443. 014

Dutilh, G., A. Sarafoglou and E.-J. Wagenmakers. 2019. "Flexible Yet Fair: Blinding Analyses in Experimental Psychology." Synthese (19 November): 1-28.

Ebersole, C., O. Atherton, A. Belanger, H. Skulborstad, J. Allen, J. Banks, E. Baranski, M. Bernstein, D. Bonfiglio, L. Boucher, E. Brown, N. Budiman, A. Cairo, C. Capaldi, C. Chartier, J. Chung, D. Cicero, J. Coleman, J. Conway ... B. Nosek. 2016. "Many Labs 3: Evaluating Participant Pool Quality across the Academic Semester via Replication." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 67: 68-82.

Etz, A., Q. F. Gronau, F. Dablander, P. A. Edelsbrunner and B. Baribault. 2018. "How to Become a Bayesian in Eight Easy Steps: An Annotated Reading List." Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 25: 219-234.

Evans, E. M. 2001. "Cognitive and Contextual Factors in the Emergence of Diverse Belief Systems: Creation versus Evolution." Cognitive Psychology 42(3): 217-266. 10.1006/cogp.2001.0749

Forsell, E., D. Viganola, T. Pfeiffer, J. Almenberg, B. Wilson, Y. Chen, B. A. Nosek, M. Johannesson and A. Dreber. 2018. "Predicting Replication Outcomes in the Many Labs 2 Study." Journal of Economic Psychology 75 (25 October): 1-16.

Francis, G. 2013. "Replication, Statistical Consistency, and Publication Bias." Journal of Mathematical Psychology 57: 153-169.

Frank, M. C., E. Bergelson, C. Bergmann, A. Cristia, C. Floccia, J. Gervain, J. K. Hamlin, E. E. Hannon, M. Kline, C. Levelt, C. Lew-Williams, T. Nazzi, R. Panneton, H. Rabagliati, M. Soderstrom, J. Sullivan, S. Waxman and D. Yurovsky. 2017. "A Collaborative Approach to Infant Research: Promoting Reproducibility, Best Practices, and Theory-Building." Infancy 22: 421-435. 1111/infa.12182

Gervais, W. M., S. E. McKee and S. Malik. 2020. "Do Religious Primes Increase Risk Taking? Evidence against 'Anticipating Divine Protection' in Two Preregistered Direct Replications of Kupor, Laurin, and Levav (2015)." Psychological Science 31: 858-864.

Gervais, W. M. and A. Norenzayan. 2012. "Analytic Thinking Promotes Religious Disbelief." Science 336: 493-496.

Gervais, W. M., A. K. Willard, A. Norenzayan and J. Henrich. 2011. "The Cultural Transmission of Faith: Why Innate Intuitions Are Necessary, but Insufficient, to Explain Religious Belief." Religion 41: 389-410.

Gervais, W. M., D. Xygalatas, R. T. McKay, M. van Elk, E. E. Buchtel, M. Aveyard, S. R. Schiavone, I. Dar-Nimrod, A. M. Svedholm-Häkkinen, T. Riekki, E. Kundtova Klocová, J. E. Ramsay and J. Bulbulia. 2017. "Global Evidence of Extreme Intuitive Moral Prejudice against Atheists." Nature Human Behaviour 1: 0151 (1-6).

Gewin, V. 2016. "Data Sharing: An Open Mind on Open Data." Nature 529: 117-119.

Gilder, T. S. E. and E. A. Heerey. 2018. "The Role of Experimenter Belief in Social Priming." Psychological Science 29: 403-417.

Gilmore, R. O., J. L. Kennedy and K. E. Adolph. 2018. "Practical Solutions for Sharing Data and Materials from Psychological Research." Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Science 1: 121-130.

Gomes, C. M. and M. E. McCullough. 2015. "The Effects of Implicit Religious Primes on Dictator Game Allocations: A Preregistered Replication Experiment." Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 144: e94-e104.

Haaf, J. M., S. Hoogeveen, S. Berkhout, Q. F. Gronau and E.-J. Wagenmakers. 2020. "A Bayesian Multiverse Analysis of Many Labs 4: Quantifying the Evidence against Mortality Salience." (Preprint). PsyArXiv.

Haith, M. M. 1998. "Who Put the Cog in Infant Cognition? Is Rich Interpretation Too Costly?" Infant Behavior and Development 21: 167-179.

Hardwicke, T. E., M. B. Mathur, K. MacDonald, G. Nilsonne, G. C. Banks, M. C. Kidwell, A. Hofelich Mohr, E. Clayton, E. J. Yoon, M. Henry Tessler ... M. C. Frank. 2018. "Data Availability, Reusability, and Analytic Reproducibility: Evaluating the Impact of a Mandatory Open Data Policy at the journal Cognition." Royal Society Open Science 5: 180448 (1-18).

Hardwicke, T. E., M. H. Tessler, B. Peloquin and M. C. Frank. 2018. "A Bayesian Decision-Making Framework for Replication." Behavioral and Brain Sciences 41: e132. https: //

Hardy, A. 1981. The Spiritual Nature of Man: A Study of Contemporary Religious Experience. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Harris, P. and M. Giménez. 2005. "Children's Acceptance of Conflicting Testimony: The Case of Death." Journal of Cognition and Culture 5: 143-164. 1163/1568537054068606

Harris, S., J. T. Kaplan, A. Curiel, S. Y. Bookheimer, M. Iacoboni and M. S. Cohen. 2009. "The Neural Correlates of Religious and Nonreligious Belief." PLoS ONE 4(10): e7272 (1-9).

Hone, L. S. E. and M. E. McCullough. 2015. "Does Religious Cognition Really Down-Regulate Hand Grip Endurance in Men? A Failure to Replicate." Evolution and Human Behavior 36: 81-85.

Hoogeveen, S., A. Sarafoglou and E.-J. Wagenmakers. 2020. "Laypeople Can Predict Which Social-Science Studies Will Be Replicated Successfully." Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Science, 1-19.

Hoogeveen, S., L. Snoek and M. van Elk. 2020. "Religious Belief and Cognitive Conflict Sensitivity: A Preregistered fMRI Study." Cortex 129: 247-265. 1016/j.cortex.2020.04.011

Hoogeveen, S., E.-J. Wagenmakers, A. C. Kay and M. van Elk. 2018. "Compensatory Control and Religious Beliefs: A Registered Replication Report across Two Countries." Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology 3: 240-265. 23743603.2019.1684821

Huber, D. E., K. W. Potter and L. D. Huszar. 2019. "Less 'Story' and More 'Reliability' in Cognitive Neuroscience." Cortex 113: 347.

Inzlicht, M., I. McGregor, J. B. Hirsh and K. Nash. 2009. "Neural Markers of Religious Conviction." Psychological Science 20: 385-392.

Inzlicht, M., A. M. Tullett and M. Good. 2011. "The Need to Believe: A Neuroscience Account of Religion as a Motivated Process." Religion, Brain & Behavior 1: 192-212. https: //

Ioannidis, J. P. A. 2005. "Why Most Published Research Findings Are False." PLoS Medicine 2: 696-701.

JASP Team. 2019. JASP (version 0.11.1) [Computer software].

John, L. K., G. Loewenstein and D. Prelec. 2012. "Measuring the Prevalence of Questionable Research Practices with Incentives for Truth-Telling." Psychological Science 23: 524-532.

Jong, J., J. Halberstadt, M. Bluemke, C. Kavanagh and C. Jackson. 2019. "Death Anxiety, Exposure to Death, Mortuary Preferences, and Religiosity in Five Countries." Scientific Data 6: 154 (1-5).

Kavanagh, C. M., J. Jong, R. McKay and H. Whitehouse. 2018. "Positive Experiences of High Arousal Martial Arts Rituals Are Linked to Identity Fusion and Costly Pro-Group Actions." European Journal of Social Psychology 49(3): 461-481. 2514

Kavanagh, C. M. and R. Kapitany. 2017/2019. "Promoting the Benefits and Clarifying Misconceptions about Preregistration, Preprints, and Open Science for Cognitive Science of Religion." Journal for the Cognitive Science of Religion 5(2).

Kay, A. C., D. Gaucher, J. L. Napier, M. J. Callan and K. Laurin. 2008. "God and the Government: Testing a Compensatory Control Mechanism for the Support of External Systems." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 95: 18-35.

Kelemen, D. 2004. "Are Children 'Intuitive Theists'? Reasoning about Purpose and Design in Nature." Psychological Science 15: 295-301.

Kidwell, M. C., L. B. Lazarević, E. Baranski, T. E. Hardwicke, S. Piechowski, L. Falkenberg, C. Kennett, A. Slowik, C. Sonnleitner, C. Hess-Holden, T. M. Errington, S. Fiedler and B. A. Nosek. 2016. "Badges to Acknowledge Open Practices: A Simple, Low Cost, Effective Method for Increasing Transparency." PLoS Biology 14: e1002456 (1-15).

Klein, O., T. E. Hardwicke, F. Aust, J. Breuer, H. Danielsson, A. Hofelich Mohr, H. IJzerman, G. Nilsonne, W. Vanpaemel and M. C. Frank. 2018. "A Practical Guide for Transparency in Psychological Science." Collabra: Psychology 4: 1-15. https://

Klein, R., C. L. Cook, C. R. Ebersole, C. A. Vitiello, B. A. Nosek, C. R. Chartier, C. D. Christopherson, S. Clay, B. Collisson, J. Crawford, R. Cromar, D. Vidamuerte, G. Gardiner, C. Gosnell, J. E. Grahe, C. Hall, J. A. Joy-Gaba, A. M. Legg, C. Levitan ... K. A. Ratliff. 2019. "Many Labs 4: Failure to Replicate Mortality Salience Effect with and without Original Author Involvement." (Preprint). PsyArXiv.

Klein, R., K. Ratliff, M. Vianello, R. B. Adams, Jr., S. Bahńik, M. Bernstein, K. Bocian, M. Brandt, B. Brooks, C. Brumbaugh, Z. Cemalcilar, J. Chandler, W. Cheong, W. Davis, T. Devos, M. Eisner, N. Frankowska, D. Furrow, E. M. Galliani ... B. Nosek. 2014. "Investigating Variation in Replicability: A 'Many Labs' Replication Project." Social Psychology 45: 142-152. a000178

Klein, R., M. Vianello, F. Hasselman, B. Adams, R. Adams, S. Alper, M. Aveyard, J. Axt, S. Bahník, R. Batra, M. Berkics, M. Bernstein, D. Berry, O. Bialobrzeska, E. Binan, K. Bocian, M. Brandt, R. Busching, A. Redei ... B. Nosek. 2018. "Many Labs 2: Investigating Variation in Replicability across Sample and Setting." Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Science 1: 443-490.

Konvalinka, I., D. Xygalatas, J. Bulbulia, U. Schjødt, E.-M. Jegindø, S. Wallot, G. Van Orden and A. Roepstorff. 2011. "Synchronized Arousal between Performers and Related Spectators in a Fire-Walking Ritual." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108: 8514-8519.

Kupor, D. M., K. Laurin and J. Levav. 2015. "Anticipating Divine Protection? Reminders of God Can Increase Nonmoral Risk Taking." Psychological Science 26: 374-384.

Leshinskaya, A., J. M. Contreras, A. Caramazza and J. P. Mitchell. 2017. "Neural Representations of Belief Concepts: A Representational Similarity Approach to Social Semantics." Cerebral Cortex 27(1): 344-357.

Luhrmann, T. M. 2005. "The Art of Hearing God: Absorption, Dissociation, and Contemporary American Spirituality." Spiritus: A Journal of Christian Spirituality 5: 133-157.

----. 2012. When God Talks Back: Understanding the American Evangelical Relationship with God. New York, Vintage Books.

Luhrmann, T. M., R. Padmavati, H. Tharoor and A. Osei. 2015. "Hearing Voices in Different Cultures: A Social Kindling Hypothesis." Topics in Cognitive Science 7: 646-663.

MacCoun, R. and S. Perlmutter. 2015. "Hide Results to Seek the Truth." Nature 526: 187- 189.

Makel, M. C., J. A. Plucker and B. Hegarty. 2012. "Replications in Psychology Research: How Often Do They Really Occur?" Perspectives on Psychological Science 7: 537- 542.

Makris, N. and D. Pnevmatikos. 2007. "Children's Understanding of Human and Supernatural Mind." Cognitive Development 22: 365-375. cogdev.2006.12.003

McCullough, M. E., E. C. Carter, C. N. DeWall and C. M. Corrales. 2012. "Religious Cognition Down-Regulates Sexually Selected, Characteristically Male Behaviors in Men, but Not in Women." Evolution and Human Behavior 33: 562-568. 10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2012.02.004

McPhetres, J. 2018. "Religiosity and Confirmation Bias or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Preregistered Direct Replications." OSF Preprints.