Paganism, Archaeology and Folklore in Twenty-first Century Britain: A Case Study of ‘The Stonehenge Ancestors’
Issue: Vol 28 No. 2 (2015) Religion, Archaeology and Folklore
Journal: Journal for the Academic Study of Religion
Subject Areas: Religious Studies Buddhist Studies Islamic Studies Biblical Studies
Abstract:
Previous scholarship on Paganism and archaeology has considered Pagan engagements with prehistoric ‘sacred sites’ as ‘new folklore’, examining how Pagan meanings are inscribed and constituted. Earlier work has also highlighted the importance of respect, dialogue and working together, to promote understanding and resolve tensions between Pagans and archaeologists. But antagonism endures: the ‘Avebury Consultation’ on reburial, for instance, resulting from certain Druid calls for the reburial of ancient human remains kept in the Alexander Keiller Museum; and heated exchanges between a group of Druids and archaeologists during excavations of cremated human remains from Aubrey hole 7 at Stonehenge. I focus on the latter case in which a new Pagan folklore of ‘the Stonehenge Guardians’ has emerged, partly based on archaeologists’ recent interpretations of Stonehenge, used by this minority of Pagans in protests against the long-term retention of human remains and to argue for their reburial. I conclude by reiterating how Pagans and archaeologists should and can work together.
Author: Robert J. Wallis
References :
Australia ICOMOS
1999 The Burra Charter (The Australia ICOMOS Charter for Places of Cultural Significance 1999, with associated Guidelines and ode on the Ethics of Co-existence. Online: http://australia.icomos.org/wp-content/uploads/BURRA_CHARTER.pdf (accessed August 26, 2013).
BBC News England
2013 Richard III: King's reburial row goes to judicial review. (16 August). Online: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-23726011 (accessed August 26, 2013).
BBC News Glasgow and West Scotland
2010 Queen of the Inch to be re-interred. (18 August 2010). Online: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-11010977 (accessed August 31, 2010).
BBC News Norfolk
2012 Bressingham’s Saxon skeleton given Christian funeral. (12 October). Online: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-norfolk-19913637 (accessed August 26, 2013).
BBC News Wiltshire
2011 King Arthur Pendragon loses human remains legal battle. (23 August). Online: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-wiltshire-14630468 (accessed August 26, 2013).
BBC News Wiltshire
2013 King Arthur Pendragon loses second Stonehenge fight. (16 May). Online: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-wiltshire-22558293 (accessed June 12, 2013).
Bender, Barbara
1998 Stonehenge: Making Space. Berg, Oxford.
Bienkowski, Piotr and Malcolm Chapman
2009 Authority and Decision-Making over British Human Remains: Issues and Challenges. In Proceedings of the Ninth Annual Conference of the British Association for Biological Anthropology and Osteoarchaeology, Department of Archaeology, University of Reading 2007, edited by Mary E. Lewis and Margaret Clegg, 99-105. BAR International Series 1918. Archaeopress, Oxford.
Blain, Jenny and Robert J. Wallis
2002 A living landscape? Pagans and archaeological discourse. 3rd
Stone: Archaeology, Folklore and Myth – The Magazine for the New Antiquarian, 43: 20-7.
Blain, Jenny and Robert J. Wallis
2007 Sacred Sites, Contested Rites/Rights: Pagan Engagements with Archaeological Monuments. Sussex Academic Press, Brighton.
Blain, Jenny and Robert J. Wallis
2012 Negotiating archaeology/spirituality: Pagan engagements with the prehistoric past in Britain. In Archaeology of Spiritualities, edited by Kathryn Rountree, Christine Morris and Alan A. D. Peatfield, 47-68. One World Archaeology Series. Springer, London and New York.
British Archaeology
2011 News: Human remains to be retained, pending details. British Archaeology, 118 (May/June). Online: http://www.archaeologyuk.org/ba/ba118/news.shtmlhttp://www.archaeologyuk.org/ba/ba118/news.shtml (accessed August 26, 2013).
Cope, Julian
1998 The Modern Antiquarian: A Pre-Millennial Odyssey Through Megalithic
Britain. Thorsons, London.
2004 The Megalithic European. Element, London.
Crawford, O.G.S.
1957 The Eye Goddess. Phoenix House, London.
Crook, Simon
1998 Away with the Fairies: Rock Art and Psychic Geography in West Yorkshire. MA diss, Department of Archaeology, University of Southampton.
Crook, Simon
2012 ‘Til the Cows Come Home 2: The Social Life of Megaliths. Northern Earth, 129: 16-
22.
Crook, Simon
2013 An Apport in Merry Oak: Shades of the Cottingley Fairies? Online: http://thegrammarofmatter.wordpress.com/tag/cottingley-fairies/ (accessed June 20, 2014).
Cusack, Carol
2012 Charmed Circle: Stonehenge, Contemporary Paganism, and Alternate Archaeologies. Numen, 59: 138-155.
Dames, Michael
1976 The Silbury Treasure. Thames and Hudson, London.
Dames, Michael
1977 The Avebury Cycle. Thames and Hudson, London.
Darvill, Tim, Geoff Wainwright, Kayt Armstrong and Rob A. Ixer
2009 Strumble-Preseli ancient communities and environment study (SPACES): Sixth report 2007-08. Archaeology in Wales, 48: 47-56.
Dawkins, Richard
2006 The God Delusion. Bantam Press, London.
DCMS (Department of Culture, Media and Sport)
2005 Guidance for the Care of Human Remains in Museums. Online: https://www.britishmuseum.org/pdf/DCMS%20Guide.pdf (accessed June 20, 2014).
Denning, Kathryn
1999 Apocalypse Past/Future: Archaeology and Folklore, Writ Large. In Archaeology and Folklore, edited by Cornelius Holtorf and Amy Gazin-Schwartz, 90-105. Routledge, London
Devereux, Paul
1990 Places of Power: Secret Energies at Ancient Sites: A Guide to Observed or Measured Phenomenon. Blandford, London.
Fagan, Garrett G. and Kenneth L. Feder
2006 Crusading against straw men: an alternative view of alternative archaeologies: response to Holtorf (2005). World Archaeology, 38(4): 718-729.
Ford, Nick.
2009 'Honouring the Ancient Dead': The Care of Elderly Souls and the Rights of Bone Fragments to a Quiet Life. Online: http://pagantheologies.pbworks.com/w/page/13622300/The%20Care%20of%20Elderly%20Souls%20and%20the%20Rights%20of%20Bone%20Fragments%20to%20a%20Quiet%20Life (accessed January 13 2015).
Gimbutas, Marija
1974 The Gods and Goddesses of Old Europe: 7000-3500 B.C. Thames and Hudson, London and University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles.
Gimbutas, Marija with Miriam Robbins Dexter (as editor)
1999 The Living Goddesses. University of California Press, London, Berkeley and Los Angeles.
Glazier, D.
2005 A Different Way of Seeing? Toward a Visual Analysis of Archaeological Folklore. In Envisioning the Past: Archaeology and the Image, edited by Sam Smiles and Stephanie Moser, 158–179. Oxford, Blackwell.
The Guardian
2011 Letters: Reburial requirement impedes archaeology: signed by 40 UK archaeology professors. The Guardian (4 February 2011). Online: http://www.theguardian.com/science/2011/feb/04/reburial-requirement-impedes-archaeology (accessed August 26, 2013).
Gyrus
1998 The Goddess in Wharfedale. Online:
http://dreamflesh.com/essays/wharfedalegoddess/ (accessed June 20, 2014).
Honouring the Ancient Dead (HAD)
2009 Press Release on the Consultation on the Request for Reburial of Human Remains, Avebury, Wiltshire, February 2009. Online: www.sacredsites.org.uk/news/HAD%20Press%20Release.pdf (accessed June 20, 2014).
Haraway, Donna
2007 When Species Meet. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
Holtorf, Cornelius
2005 Beyond crusades: how (not) to engage with alternative archaeologies. World Archaeology 37(4): 544-541.
Holtorf, Cornelius and Amy Gazin-Schwartz (eds)
1999 Archaeology and Folklore. Routledge: London.
Hutton, Ronald
2003 Witches, Druids and King Arthur. Hambledon and London, London and New York.
Ingold, Tim
2006 Rethinking the Animate, Re-Animating Thought. Ethnos 71(1): 9-20.
Jacobs, Rebbeca
2009 National Trust / English Heritage Avebury Reburial Consultation: response, January 2009. Online http://www.museumsassociation.org/news/17777 (accessed August 26, 2013).
Jenkins, Tiffany
2010 Contesting Human Remains in Museum Collections: The Crisis of Cultural Authority. Routledge, London.
Jones, A.
2001 Archaeological Theory and Scientific Practice. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Jones, D.
2008a Dispatch from Stonehenge, Day 1: March 31st: The Excavation Begins. Online
http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/dispatch-from-stonehenge-day-1-33099770/
(accessed January 11, 2015).
Jones, D.
2008b Dispatch from Stonehenge, Day 14: April 13th: The Druids Bless our Departure.
Online: http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/dispatch-from-stonehenge-day-14-36238068/?no-ist (accessed January 11, 2015).
Kerton, Nigel
2007 Druids Call for Reburial. Wiltshire Gazette & Herald (2 February). Online: www.gazetteandherald.co.uk/mostpopular.var.1164290.mostviewed.druids_call_for_burial.php (accessed June 20, 2014).
Latour, Bruni
1993 We Have Never Been Modern. Cambridge, Harvard University Press, Massachusetts.
Letcher, Andy
2001 The Scouring of the Shire: Fairies, Trolls and Pixies in Eco-Protest Culture.
Folklore 112: 147-61.
Letcher, Andy, Jenny Blain and Robert. J. Wallis
2009 Re-viewing the past: discourse and power in images of prehistory. In The Framed World: Tourism, Tourists and Photography, edited by Mike Robinson and David Picard, 169-183. Ashgate, Farnham, Surrey.
Lucas, Phillip C.
2007 Constructing identities with dreamstones: megalithic sites and contemporary nature spirituality. Nova Religio 11(1): 31-60.
Maffesoli, Michel
1996 The Time of the Tribes: The Decline of Individualism in Mass Society. Sag, London.
Meskell, Lynn
1995 Goddesses, Gimbutas and 'New Age' Archaeology. Antiquity 69: 74-86.
Meskell, Lynn
1998 Oh My Goddess! Archaeology, Sexuality and Ecofeminism. Archaeological Dialogues 5(2): 126-143.
Meskell, Lynn
1999 Feminism, Paganism, Pluralism. In Archaeology and Folklore, edited by Cornelius Holtorf and Amy Gazin-Schwartz, 83-89. Routledge, London.
Michell, John
1969 The View Over Atlantis. Sago Press, London.
Moser, Stephanie, Darren Glazier, James E. Philips, Layma Nasser el Nemer, Mohammed Saleh Mousa, Rascha Nasr Aiesh, Susan Richardson, Andrew Conner and Michael Seymour
2002 Transforming Archaeology through Practice: Strategies for Collaborative Practice in the Community Archaeology Project at Quseir, Egypt. World Archaeology 34(2): 220-248.
Moshenska, Gabe, Mike Parker Pearson and Tim Schadla-Hall
2011 Resolving the Human Remains Crisis in British Archaeology: Response to Sayer, Pitts, Pendragon, Elders, Lapinoja and Sutphin. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 21: 31-33.
Oakley, G. T.
1988 Verbeia: Goddess of Wharfedale. Rooted Media, Leeds.
Paphitis, T.
2013 ‘Have You Come to Take the King Away?’: A Survey of Archaeology and Folklore in Context. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 23(1):16. Online: http://dx.doi.org/10.5334/pia.434 (accessed January 25, 2015)
Parker Pearson, Mike
2012 Stonehenge: Exploring the Greatest Stone Age Mystery. Simon and Schuster, London.
Parker Pearson, Mike, Andrew Chamberlain, Mandy Jay, Peter Marshall, Josh Pollard, Colin Richards, Julian Thomas, Chris Tilley and Kate Welham
2009 Who was buried at Stonehenge? Antiquity 83: 23-39.
Parkins, E.
2008 Stonehenge: Timewatch Team Diary. Online: http://www.open.edu/openlearn/history-the-arts/history/heritage/stonehenge-timewatch-team-diary (accessed January 11 2015).
Pendragon, Arthur
2008 The bones removal blessing protest – August 2008. Online: www.warband.org.uk/bones-blessing-protest.html (accessed May 14, 2013).
Pendragon, Arthur
2011 Resolving the Human Remains Crisis in British Archaeology: The Counter Argument. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 21: 23-27.
Pitts, Mike
2011 Digging Deeper: Comment on Resolving the Human Remains Crisis in British Archaeology. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 21: 20-22.
Pope, M.
2013 Letters: ‘Natives’. British Archaeology 131 (July/August): 10.
Rathouse, Will
2014 Contesting the Ancestors. Unpublished conference paper. Online: https://www.academia.edu/7260739/Contesting_the_Ancestors (accessed June 20, 2014).
Restall Orr, Emma
Forthcoming A Singular Empathy: An Animistic Understanding in a Dualist Culture. In Pagans, Archaeologists and Ancestors: Perspectives on Prehistoric Human Remains in Britain Today, edited by Robert J. Wallis and Jenny Blain.
Rountree, Kathryn
2004 Embracing the Witch and the Goddess: Feminist Ritual-makers in New Zealand, London and New York, Routledge.
Rountree, Kathryn
2007 Archaeologists and Goddess Feminists at Çatalhöyük: An Experiment in Multivocality. Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion 23(2): 7-26.
Rountree, Kathryn
2010 Crafting Contemporary Pagan Identities in a Catholic Society. Ashgate, London.
Sample, Ian
2011 Legislation forces archaeologists to rebury finds. The Guardian (4 February). Online: http://www.theguardian.com/science/2011/feb/04/archaeologists-forced-to-rebury-finds (accessed August 26, 2013).
Sayer, Duncan
2009 Is there a crisis facing British burial archaeology? Antiquity 83: 199-205.
Schadla-Hall, Tim
2004 The comforts of unreason: the importance and relevance of alternative archaeology. In Public Archaeology, edited by Nick Merriman, 255-271. Routledge, London.
Shallcrass, Philip.
Forthcoming. Living with the Dead. In Pagans, Archaeologists and Ancestors: Perspectives on Prehistoric Human Remains in Britain Today, edited by Robert J. Wallis and Jenny Blain.
Sitch, Bryan
2007 Lindow Man Consultation, Saturday 10th February 2007: Report. Online: www.museum.manchester.ac.uk/aboutus/ourpractice/lindowman/fi leuploadmax10mb,120485,en.pdf (accessed 3 August, 2014).
Sitch, Bryan
Forthcoming. Archaeology, the Ancestors and the Public: The Manchester Museum’s Lindow Man a Bog Body Mystery Exhibition. In Pagans, Archaeologists and Ancestors: Perspectives on Prehistoric Human Remains in Britain Today, edited by Robert J. Wallis and Jenny Blain.
Smith, LauraJane
2006 Uses of Heritage. Routledge, London.
Sutphin, Amanda
2011 Resolving the Human Remains Crisis in British Archaeology: A Response. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 21: 29-30.
Swidler, Nina, E., Kurt Dongoske, Roger Anyon and Alan S. Downer (eds)
1997 Native Americans and Archaeologists: Stepping Stones to Common Ground. AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California.
Thackray, David and Sebastian Payne
2008 Draft Report on the Request for the Reburial of Human Remains From the Alexander Keiller Museum at Avebury. London and Swindon: National Trust and English Heritage. Online: www.englishheritage.org.uk/upload/pdf/Draft_report.pdf?1241669300 (accessed 3 August 2014).
Thackray, David and Sebastian Payne
2010 Avebury Reburial Request: Summary Report. London and Swindon: National Trust and English Heritage. Online: http://www.english-heritage.org.uk/content/imported-docs/a-e/avebury-reburial-request-summary.pdf (accessed June 20, 2014)
Thomas, J.
2004 Archaeology and Modernity. London, Routledge.
WAC (World Archaeological Congress)
1989 The Vermillion Accord on Human Remains. Online: http://www.worldarchaeologicalcongress.org/site/about_ethi.php#code2 (accessed January 25, 2015).
WAC (World Archaeological Congress)
2005 The Tamaki Makau-rau Accord on the Display of Human Remains and Sacred Objects. Online: http://www.worldarchaeologicalcongress.org/site/about_ethi.php#code2 (accessed January 25, 2015).
Wallis, Robert J.
2003 Shamans / neo-Shamans: Ecstasy, Alternative Archaeologies and Contemporary Pagans. Routledge, London.
Wallis, Robert J.
2012 Pagans in place, from Stonehenge to Seahenge: ‘sacred’ archaeological monuments and artefacts in Britain. In Art, Faith and Place in East Anglia: From Prehistory to the Present, edited by T. A. Heslop, Elizabeth Mellings and Margit Thøfner, 273-286. Boydell & Brewer, Woodbridge, Suffolk.
Wallis, Robert J. and Jenny Blain
2004 Sacred sites, contested rites/rights: contemporary Pagan engagements with the past. Journal of Material Culture 9(3): 237-261.
Wallis, Robert J. and Jenny Blain
2006 Pasts and Pagan practices: moving beyond Stonehenge. Public Archaeology 5(4): 211-222.
Wallis, Robert J. and Jenny Blain
2009 ‘Sacred’ sites, artefacts and museum collections: Pagan engagements with archaeology in Britain. In Handbook of Contemporary Paganism edited by Jim Lewis and Murph Pizza, 591-609. Brill Handbooks on Contemporary Religion 2. Brill Academic Publishers, Leiden and Boston.
Wallis, Robert J. and Jenny Blain
2011 From respect to reburial: negotiating Pagan interest in prehistoric human remains in Britain, through the Avebury consultation. Public Archaeology 10(1): 23 45.
Wallis, Robert J. and Kenneth Lymer (eds)
2001 A Permeability of Boundaries: New Approaches to the Archaeology of Art, Religion and Folklore. BAR International Series 936. British Archaeological Reports, Oxford.
Warband
n.d. Judicial Review. Online: http://www.warband.co.uk/judicial-review.html (accessed August 26, 2013).
Watkins, Alfred
1925 The Old Straight Track. Methuen and Company, London.
Williams, Mr Justice Wyn
2011 Judgement in the High Court of Justice in the case of King Arthur Pendragon v. Ministry of Justice. Online www.warband.org.uk/judicial-review.html (accessed May 14, 2013).
Williams, Tom
2011 Editorial: PIA at 21 and the Human Remains Crisis. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 21: 1-4.
Worthington, Andy
2004 Stonehenge: Celebration and Subversion. Heart of Albion Press, Loughborough.
Worthington, Andy
2009 Mystics and mavericks: the Pagan reinvention of Avebury. In Written on Stone: The Cultural Reception of British Prehistoric Monuments, edited by Joanne Parker, 100-110. Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne.
Young, D.
2015 Background: Burra Charter. Online: http://www.hbp.usm.my/cad/Q&A/Charter/Q&ABurra.htm (accessed January 25, 2015).