The Church, The Commission and the Truth: Inside the NSW Special Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse
Issue: Vol 29 No. 1 (2016)
Journal: Journal for the Academic Study of Religion
Subject Areas: Religious Studies Buddhist Studies Islamic Studies Biblical Studies
Abstract:
The NSW Special Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse in the Newcastle-Maitland diocese, an area north of Sydney, Australia, held proceedings during 2013. The Special Inquiry investigated allegations made by police whistleblower Peter Fox that the Newcastle police and the Catholic Church colluded to keep criminal sexual activity against children by two Catholic priests from being properly investigated. This article reports on sections of the court hearings dealing with the Catholic Church, and relates these to sociological theories of gender, religion and power. In particular, the article will position gender analysis, via the social construction of clerical masculinity, as a central hermeneutic for understanding the culture of sexual violence which has plagued the Catholic Church in this region, and more broadly, for decades. This analysis uncovers a culture of elitist male clericalism, practices of institutional secrecy, the poor psychosexual development of priests and an exclusivist patriarchal construction of the sacred as key elements in church culture. The article makes a contribution to two areas of inquiry that are under-researched in the child sexual abuse literature: the role of gender and the culture of priesthood.
Author: Kathleen McPhillips
References :
ABC News
2012 Newcastle Catholic Bishop Supports Abuse Inquiry. July 26. Online:
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-07-26/newcastle-catholic-bishopsupports-
abuse-inquiry/4157078 (accessed June 20, 2014).
Alexander, Mary
2013 Pell Tells Inquiry of Ridsdale Support. The Standard (May 28). Online:
http://www.standard.net.au/story/1531096/pell-tells-abuse-inquiry-ofridsdale-
support/ (accessed June 24, 2014).
Armitage, Catherine
2013 ‘A Journalists Caring Ear’: Inquiry into Whistleblower Relationship.
Newcastle Herald (26 June). Online: http://www.theherald.com.au/
story/1595888/a-journalists-caring-ear-inquiry-into-whistleblowerrelationship/
(accessed June 24, 2014).
Australian Catholic Welfare Commission and Centacare Catholic Community Services
1999 Towards Understanding: A Study of Factors Specific to the Catholic
Church which Might Lead to Sexual Abuse by Priests and Religious.
Unpublished Report, July.
Australian Law Reform Commission
2014 Sexual Assault and Family Violence: The Prevalence of Sexual
Violence. Online: http://www.alrc.gov.au/publications/24.%20Sexual%
20Assault%20and%20Family%20Violence/prevalence-sexualviolence#_
ftn7 (accessed July 26, 2014).
Catholica
2013 A Global Conversation. Online: http://www.catholica.com.au/forum/
(accessed May 31, 2014).
Condren, Mary
2008 Melting Hearts of Stone. In Post-Christian Feminisms: A Critical
Approach, edited by Lisa Isherwood and Kathleen McPhilllips, 147-68.
Ashgate, Aldershot.
Cunneen, Margaret
2014 Special Commission of Inquiry into Matters Relating to the Police
Investigation of Certain Child Sexual Abuse Allegations in the Catholic
Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle Report (May 30). Online:
http://www.lawlink.nsw.gov.au/lawlink/Special_Projects/ll_splprojects.ns
f/pages/sisa_index.
Erickson, Victoria Lee
1993 Where Silence Speaks: Feminism, Social Theory and Religion. Fortress
Press, Minneapolis.
Foucault, Michel
1988 The History of Sexuality, Vol. 1. Penguin Harmondsworth, London.
Geraghty, Chris
2002 Cassocks in the Wilderness: Remembering the Seminary at
Springwood. Spectrum Publications, Melbourne.
2003 The Priest Factory. Spectrum Publications, Melbourne.
Gogarty, Peter
2014 Opinion: Credit People Power for Special Inquiry Report. Newcastle
Herald (May 30).
Goldner, Virginia
2004 The Sexual Abuse Crisis and the Catholic Church in Studies. Gender
and Sexuality 5(1): 1-9.
Goode, Sarah
2011 Encountering Paedophiles in Society. Palgrave McMillan, Basingstoke.
Gordon, Jason
2014 Ex-bishop Michael Malone Says Evidence Misinterpreted. Newcastle
Herald (June 3).
Herman, Judith Lewis
1997 Trauma and Recovery. Pandora Press, London.
Keenan, Marie
2012 Child Sexual Abuse and the Catholic Church: Gender Power and
Organizational Power. Oxford University, Press, Oxford.
Kelly, Liz
1996 Weasel Words: Paedophiles and the Cycle of Abuse. Trouble and Strife
33: 1-8.
Kirkwood, Ian, and Joanne McCarthy
2013 PM’s letter to Herald Journalist Joanne McCarthy. Newcastle Herald
(September 13). Online: http://www.theherald.com.au/story/1775058/
pms-letter-to-herald-journalist-joanne-mccarthy/.
Lee, Jane
2013 Pell Blames Inaction: Loose Entry Standards. The Age (May 27).
Online: http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/pell-blames-inaction-looseentry-
standards-20130527-2n6pk.html.
Livingston, Tess
2014 Mud on Boots of New Chief Catholic Anthony Fisher. The Australian
(September 19). Online: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/nation/
mud-on-boots-of-new-chief-catholic-anthony-fisher/story-e6frg6nf-
122706335865.
McCarthy, Joanne
2015a Paedophile Priest Jailed. Newcastle Herald (23 January). Online:
http://www.theherald.com.au/story/2837254/paedophile-priest-johndenham-
jailed/.
2015b Bishop Urged to take Stronger Action over Retiring Priests. Newcastle
Herald (15 February). Online: http://www.theherald.com.au/
story/2885252/bishop-urged-to-take-stronger-action-over-retiringpriests/
McGillion, Chris, and John O’Caroll
2011 Our Fathers: What Australian Catholic Priests Really Think about their
Lives and their Church. John Jarratt Publishing, Victoria.
McGillion, Chris, and Damien Grace
2014 Reckoning: The Catholic Church and Child Sexual Abuse. ATF Press,
Adelaide.
McPhillips, Kathleen
2008 De-colonizing the Sacred: Feminist Proposals for a Post-Christian, Post-
Patriarchal Sacred. In Post-Christian Feminisms: A Critical Approach,
edited by Lisa Isherwood and Kathleen McPhillips, 129-46. Ashgate,
Aldershot.
Marr, David
2013 The Prince: Faith, Abuse and George Pell. Quarterly Essay 51: 1-98.
Medley, Mary
2001 Sacred and Profane: Sacred and Violent: Towards Understanding
Priestly Sexual Violence. PhD diss., University of Wollongong.
Middleton, W., P. Stavropoulos, M.J. Dorahy, D. Druger, R. Lewis-Fernandez, A.
Martinez-Taboas, V. Sar, and B. Brand
2014 The Australian Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child
Sexual Abuse. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 48
(1): 17-21.
Owen, Michael
2010 I Never Covered Up Abuse, Says Archbishop Phillip Wilson. The
Australian (May 22). Online: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/
nation/i-never-covered-up-abuse-says-archbishop/story-e6frg6nf-
1225869812505 (accessed June 22, 2014).
Robinson, Geoffrey
2007 Confronting Power and Sex in the Catholic Church. Liturgical Press,
Collegeville, MN.
Ronken, C., and H. Johnston
2012 Child Sexual Assault: Facts and Statistics. In Report Bravehearts
Organisation, December. Online: http://www.bravehearts.org.au/files/
(accessed June 24, 2014).
Swain, Shurley
2015 Giving Voice to Narratives of Institutional Sex Abuse. Australian
Feminist Law Review 41(2): 289-304.
Terry, Karen, Margaret Leland Smith, Katarina Schuth, James Kelly, Brenda Vollman
and Christina Massey
2011 The Causes and Context of Sexual Abuse by Catholic Priests in the
United States, 1950–2010. John Jay College, New York.
Victorian Parliament
2013 Betrayal of Trust: Inquiry into the Handling of Child Abuse by Religious
and other Non-government Organisations. Family and Community
Development Committee, Victoria.
Warner, Marina
2000 Alone of All Her Sex: The Myth and Cult of the Virgin Mary. Vintage
Books, New York.
Wright, Katie
2014 Childhood, Public Inquiries and Late Modernity. In Challenging
Identities, Institutions and Communities. Refereed Proceedings of the
Australian Sociological Association Conference, edited by B. West, 1-
10. University of South Australia, Adelaide.