Non-scientific Archaeological Recovery of Human Remains from an Ancient Well in India: Challenges in their Identification
Issue: Vol 1 No. 1 (2017)
Journal: Archaeological and Environmental Forensic Science
Subject Areas:
DOI: 10.1558/aefs.32475
Abstract:
Forensic archaeology is a scientific discipline that can expose past crime(s) against humanity by recovering the bodies of victims and meticulously documenting any proof of torture, trauma or human rights violations. Archaeological recovery of human remains deposited in pre-existing structures or features such as wells, potholes, natural ravines, roadside trenches, sewage systems etc., have been reported from many sites worldwide. In April, 2014, thousands of human bones, teeth as well as a number of personal effects including coins, medals and beaded armbands were unscientifically excavated from a well—presumably dating from the nineteenth century—located under a religious structure in the heart a North Indian town. Without the assistance of scientific expertise or local administration, locals excavated the remains to verify whether the well containing human bones was a result of an event which had been documented in the written records. The unscientific excavation by locals with no formal qualifications in archaeology or anthropology, resulted in the enhanced damage and commingling of human remains limiting information on the minimum number of individuals, age-at-death, sex, pathological conditions, trauma, etc. which may have assisted in identification and a stronger corroboration with the historical records. This paper aims to emphasize that if scientific protocols had been followed—including the participation of a multidisciplinary excavation team with experts from diverse scientific disciplines like forensic archaeology, anthropology, geology, skeletal biology, history, forensic medicine etc.—data and context would have been greatly enhanced and information may have been obtained about the deceased individuals and whether they were the victims of crimes dating to the nineteenth century.
Author: J. S. Sehrawat, R. K. Pathak
References :
Berman, D. M. 2003. “Calling the wandering souls: A journey through the heartland of ethnic cleansing.” War, Literature and the Arts 15: 267–282.
Brothwell, D. R. 1981 [1963]. Digging up Bones: The Excavation, Treatment, and Study of Human Skeletal Remains. 3rd edition. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press and the British Museum ofNatural History.
Ceker, D. and W. D. Stevens. 2015. “Recovery of missing persons in Cyprus: Heavy equipment methods and techniques for complex well excavations.” Journal of Forensic Sciences 60 (6): 1529–1533. https://doi.org/10.1111/1556-4029.12854
Congram, D. and J. Sterenberg. 2009. “Grave problems in Iraq.” In Handbook of Forensic Archaeology and Anthropology, edited by S. Blau and D. H. Ubelaker, 441–453. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press.
Cooper, F. 1858. The Crisis in the Punjab: From 10th of May Until the Fall of Delhi. London: Smith Elders & Co.
Esiyok, B., Y. Balci and M. Ozbay. 2006. “Bodies recovered from wells, sewerage systems and pits: What is the cause of death?” Annals Academy of Medicine Singapore 35: 547–551.
Etxeberria F., L. Herrasti, F. Serrulll and N. Marquez-Grant. 2015. “Contemporary excavations in Spain recovering the missing from the Spanish Civil War.” In Forensic Archaeology: A Global Perspective, edited by M. Goren, N. Marquez-Grant and R. C. Janaway, 489–498. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell.
Etxeberria F., F. Serrulla and H. Herrasti. 2014. “Bodies hidden in potholes, caves and wells in the Civil War (1936–1939): Contributions of forensic anthropology.” Munibe Antropologia-Arkeologia 65: 269–288. https://doi.org/10.21630/maa.2014.65.16
Flavel A. and C. Barker. 2016. “Forensic anthropology and archaeology in Guatemala.” In Handbook of Forensic Archaeology and Anthropology, edited by J. Blau and D. H. Ubelaker, 426–440. New York: Routlege.
Fonderbrider, L. and V. Scheinsohn. 2015. “Forensic archaeology: The Argentinian way.” In Forensic Archaeology: A Global Perspective, edited by M. Goren, N. Marquez-Grant and R. C. Janaway, 369–378. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell.
Gómez-López, A. M. and A. Patiño Umaña. 2007. “Who is missing? Problems in the application of archaeology and anthropology in Colombia’s conflict.” In Forensic Archaeology and Human Rights Violations, edited by R. Ferllini, 170–204. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
Groen, M., N. Márquez-Grant and R. Janaway, eds. 2015. Forensic Archaeology: A Global Perspective. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.
Hirz, R. 1999. Republic of Austria, Federal Ministry of the Interior, Kosovo Crime Scene Team, Crimes Scene: XXI. International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, Translation 03010876
Human Rights Watch. 2004. “Iraq: State of the evidence.” Human Rights Watch Report 16(7): 1–41.
ICMP. 2004. “Summary report on the forensic monitoring activities relating to the excavation and recovery of human remains from several related features located at Batajnica, Serbia and Montenegro. August to December 2002.”
Jennings, S. 2009. “Kosovo victims’ relatives testify about mass graves.” Institute for War and Peace Research. https://iwpr.net/global-voices/kosovo-victims-relatives-testify-about-mass-graves
Jessee, E. and M. Skinner. 2005. “A typology of mass grave and mass grave-related sites.” Forensic Science International 152 (1): 55–59. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2005.02.031
Juhl, K. and O. Olsen. 2006. “Societal safety, archaeology, and the investigation of contemporary mass graves.” Journal of Genocide Research 8(4): 411–435. https://doi.org/10.1080/14623520601056257
King, T., L. T. Humphrey and S. Hilson. 2005. “Linear enamel hypoplasia as indicators of systematic physiological stress: Evidence from two known age-at-death and sex populations from postmedieval London.” American Journal of Physical Anthropology 128 (3): 547–559. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.20232
Konecna L., E. Drozdova and M. Safr. 2012. “Identifikace jedince z hromadneho hrdai.” Ceska Antropologie 61 (1): 23–28
Lecomte, D. and W. Vorhauer. 1999. “French Forensic Mission Kosovo—Summer 1999; Site Report, Cirez Site 2nd and 3rd July 1999.” International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, court document 03035631 (K017-6651–K017-6756).
Levine, L. J., H. R. Campbell and S. Rhine. 1984. “Perpendicular forensic archaeology.” In Human identification: Case studies in forensic anthropology, edited by T. A. Rathbun and J. E. Buikstra,87–95. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
Manning, D. 2001. “Srebrenica investigation: Summary of forensic evidence-mass graves exhumed in 2000.” United Nations International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia Report. The Hague: Office of the Prosecutor International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia.
Meier-Augenstein, W. 2012. “Provenancing people.” In Stable Isotope Forensics: An Introduction to Forensic Application of Stable Isotope Analysis, 190–211. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell.
Nelson, B. S. and B. Heischober. 1999. “Betel nut: A common drug used by naturalized citizens from India, Far East Asia and the South Pacific Islands.” Annals of Emergency Medicine 34: 238–243. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0196-0644(99)70239-8
Owsley, D. W., D. Strinović, M. Šlaus, D. D. Kollmann and M. L. Richardson. 1997. “Recovery and identification of civilian victims of war in Croatia.” Cultural Resource Management 19(10): 33–36.
Rai, N., G. Chaubey, L. Singh and K. Thangaraj. 2015. “The ancient DNA study of a north Indian Himalayan population.” A paper presented at 9th International Society for Applied Biological Sciences (ISABS) Conference on Forensic and Anthropologic Genetics held at Bol, Island of, Republic of Croatia, from 22–26 June, 2015. abstract No. ABS-422-ISABS-2015.
Robbins, L. M. AND M. Louis. 1986. “Hidden problems in identifying unknown skeletons in the Southeastern United States.” In Forensic Osteology: Advances in the Identification of Human Remains, edited by k. Reichs, 24–32. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
Simmons, T. 2002. “Taphonomy of a karstic cave execution site at Hrgar, Bosnia-Herzegovina.” In Advances in Forensic Taphonomy: Method, Theory, and Archaeological Perspectives edited by W. D. Haglund and M. H. Sorg, 263–275. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
Slaus, M., D. Strinovic, N. Pecina-Slaus, H. Brkic, D. Belicevic and V. Petrovecki. 2007a. “Identification and analysis of human remains recovered from wells from the 1991 War in Croatia.” Forensic Science International 171: 37–43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2006.10.003
Slaus, M., D. Strinovic, V. Petrovecki and V. Vyroubal. 2007b. “Contribution of forensic anthropology to the identification process in Croatia: Examples of victims recovered in wells.” Croatian Medical Journal 48 (4): 503–512.
Steadman, D. W. and W. D. Haglund. 2005. “The scope of anthropological contributions to human rights investigations.” Journal of Forensic Sciences 50: 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1520/JFS2004214
Sterenberg, J. 2009. “Dealing with the remains of conflict: An international response to crimes against humanity, forensic recovery, identification, and repatriation in the former Yugoslavia.” In Handbook of Forensic Anthropology and Archaeology, edited by S. Blau and D. H. Ubelaker, 416–425. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press.
Tuller, H. H. 2012. “Mass graves and human rights: Latest developments, methods, and lessons learned.” In A Companion to Forensic Anthropology, edited by D. C. Dirkmaat, 157–174. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118255377.ch8
Tuller, H. H. and M. Duric. 2006. “Keeping the pieces together: Comparison of mass grave excavation methodology.” Forensic Science International 156: 192–200. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2004.12.033
Ubelaker, D. H. 1989. “Human skeletal remains: Excavation, analysis and interpretation.” 3rd ed. Washington, DC: Taraxacum.
———. 2009. “Historical development of forensic anthropology: Perspectives from the United States.” In In Handbook of Forensic Anthropology and Archaeology, edited by S. Blau and D. H. Ubelaker, 76–86. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press.
Wright, R. 2010. “Where are the bodies? In the ground.” Public Historian 32: 96–107. https://doi.org/10.1525/tph.2010.32.1.96
Zinni, D. P. and K. M. Crowley. 2013. “Human odontology and dentition in forensic anthropology.” In Forensic Anthropology: An Introduction, edited by M. T. A. Tersigni-Tarrant and N. Shirley, 69–98. London: CRC Press.