Brook Ziporyn’s (Chinese) Buddhist Reading of Chinese Philosophy
Issue: Vol 34 No. 2 (2017)
Journal: Buddhist Studies Review
Subject Areas: Religious Studies Buddhist Studies
DOI: 10.1558/bsrv.35394
Abstract:
This review article defends Brook Ziporyn against the charge, quite common in graduate classroom discussions, if not in print, that his readings of early Chinese philosophy are ‘overly Buddhist’. These readings are found in his three most recent books: Ironies of Oneness and Difference: Coherence in Early Chinese Thought, Beyond Oneness and Difference: Li and Coherence in Chinese Buddhist Thought and Its Antecedents, and Emptiness and Omnipresence: An Essential Introduction to Tiantai Buddhism. His readings are clearly Buddhist-influenced, but this is not in and of itself problematic. The core issue is rather to what degree these ‘Buddhist elements’ are actually already existent in, and have subsequently been carried over from, early Chinese thought in the development of Chinese Buddhism. Indeed, some scholars of Chinese Buddhism have pointed out that much of the vocabulary, concepts, and logic used in schools such as Tiantai may owe more to Daoist influences than to Buddhist ones. Accordingly, Ziporyn’s ‘overly Buddhist’ approach might simply be an avenue of interpretation that is actually quite in line with the thinking in the early texts themselves, albeit one that is less familiar (i.e. an early Chinese Buddhist or Ziporyn’s approach). The article also aims to show how Ziporyn’s theory concerning the importance of ‘coherence’ in early and later Chinese philosophy is also quite important in his above work on Tiantai Buddhism, Emptiness and Omnipresence. While in this work Ziporyn almost entirely abstains from using the language of coherence, much of it actually rests on a strong coherence-based foundation, thereby demonstrating not Ziporyn’s own prejudice, but rather the thoroughgoing importance and versatility of his arguments on coherence. Indeed, understanding the importance of coherence in his readings of Tiantai Buddhism (despite the fact that he does not explicitly use coherence-related vocabulary) only bolsters the defense against the claims that he makes ‘overly Buddhist’ readings of early Chinese philosophy.
Author: Paul J. D'Ambrosio
References :
Ames, Roger T. 2011. Confucian Role Ethics: A Vocabulary. Hong Kong: Chinese University Press.
Angle, Steven. 2016. ‘Review of Ziporyn, Brook, (1) Ironies of Oneness and Difference; and (2) Beyond Oneness and Difference’. Dao 15(1): 149–157.
Chan, Alan. 2010. ‘Introduction’. Philosophy and Religion in Early Medieval China, edited by Alan K. L. Chan and Yuet-Keung Lo, 1–22. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Chen Guying 陳鼓應. 2008. Lao-Zhuang Xin Lun 老莊新論 [New theories on the Laozi and Zhuangzi]. Revised edition. Beijing: Commercial Press.
D’Ambrosio, Paul J., Hans-Rudolf Kantor and Hans-Georg Moeller. 2018. ‘Incongruent Names: A Theme in the History of Chinese Philosophy’. Dao (forthcoming).
Jia, Jinhua. 2015. ‘Redefining the Ideal Character: A Comparative Study between the Concept of Detachment in the Aṣṭasāhasrikā and Guo Xiang’s Theory of Eremitism at Court’. Dao 14(4): 545–565.
Kjellberg, Paul and Philip J. Ivanhoe, eds. 1996. Essays on Skepticism, Relativism, and Ethics in the Zhuangzi. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Moeller, Hans-Georg and Paul J. D’Ambrosio. 2017. Genuine Pretending: On the Philosophy of the Zhuangzi. New York: Columbia University Press.
Rosemont, Henry, Jr. 2015. Against Individualism: A Confucian Rethinking of the Foundation of Morality, Politics, Family, and Religion. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
Wang Bo 王博. 2004. Zhuangzi zhexue 莊子哲學 [The philosophy of Zhuangzi]. Beijing: Peking University Press.
Wang Deyou 王德有. 2010. Wei-Jin Xuanxue: Gao dao yi de xiushi rensheng 魏晉玄學:高蹈 逸的閒適人生 [Wei-Jin neo-Daoism: Leisurely living hermits]. Shanghai: Oriental Publishing Center.
Wang Fuzhi 王夫之. 1964. Zhuangzi jie 莊子解 [Annotations to the Zhuangzi]. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju.
Yang Guorong 楊國榮. 2009. Zhuangzi de sixiang shijie 莊子的思想世界 [Zhuangzi’s world of thought]. Shanghai: East China Normal University Press.
Ziporyn, Brook. 2003. The Penumbra Unbound: The Neo-Taoist Philosophy of Guo Xiang. Albany: State University of New York Press.
———. 2012. Ironies of Oneness and Difference: Coherence in Early Chinese Thought; Prolegomena to the Study of Li 理. Albany: State University of New York Press.
———. 2013. Beyond Oneness and Difference: Li 理 in Chinese Buddhist Thought and Its Antecedents. Albany: State University of New York Press.
———. 2016. Emptiness and Omnipresence: An Essential Introduction to Tiantai Buddhism. Bloomington: University of Indiana Press.