Origin and Evolution of Languages
ID: 1583 - View Book Page - Edit In OJS
With Serge Cleuziou, Jean-Paul Demoule and Pierre Encrevé
PAPERBACK PUBLISHED MAY 2009
Origin and Evolution of Languages has a strong interdisciplinary flavour designed to highlight the true complexity of the debates in the field. Many of the models and theories conjectured can only receive their validation from a convergence of arguments developed across disciplines. The book underscores this dimension by including contribution from disciplines that have been wary, traditionally, of extending beyond their borders: linguistics (different branches thereof), philosophy, history and prehistory, archaeology, anthropology, genetics, computer-modelling. The presentation is intended to encompass both the agreements and disjunctures characteristic of the field and insisted on laying open propositions that clearly differ from, possibly even enter into contradiction with one another. While several teams of researchers active in the fields of genetics, linguistics, anthropology and archaeology have come up with new proposals in favor of the “New Synthesis,” many competing hypotheses and models continue to be explored in areal linguistics, language contact, wave-like diffusion. On the anthropological scene, criticisms of the monogenetic model have set up new debates and counter-arguments. Approaching the issue of the origin and evolution of human languages within a Darwinian paradigm remains problematic. On the archaeological scene, not all reconstructions are proving compatible with current models for the circulation of techniques, myths and cultures. On the linguistic scene, raising again the issue of the origin / evolution of humankind and of languages in an evolutionary, cognitive, social and cultural perspective or in terms of generational transmission and acquisition, may induce a reconsideration of linguistic theories in search of universals as well as most theories of change and variation. All contributors are world-renowned experts in their domain.
Published: May 1, 2008
Reviews
'Parce qu’il est sans doute un exemple de positionnement stratégique au sein d’une problématique éminemment discutable et discutée, je ne peux que recommander la lecture de cet ouvrage aussi bien aux étudiants et aux universitaires qu’à ceux qui souhaitent à la fois avoir un peu d’information de première main et prendre un peu de distance par rapport à ce qui est dit.'
Robert Nicolaï, Université de Nice Sophia Antipolis, Natures Sciences Sociétés 18 (2010)