Item Details

Classic and Revisionist Sociocultural Theory, and their analyses of expressive language: An empirical and theoretical assessment

Issue: Vol 2 No. 1 (2015)

Journal: Language and Sociocultural Theory

Subject Areas: Writing and Composition Linguistics

DOI: 10.1558/lst.v2i1.26988


This article articulates two approaches to sociocultural theory, Vygotsky’s classic approach and a contemporary revisionist approach. We examine: (1) their principle tenets for understanding psychology in relation to culture; (2) how they characterize and explain language in particular; and (3) how they characterize and explain a sample linguistic specimen of two dialogues from a middle-class child and a lower-class child.
I utilize a critical discourse analysis of the dialogues to empirically determine: (1) which of the two approaches better accounts for the discursive differences; (2) which is a more adequate linguistic theory; (3) which is a more adequate approach to SCT; and (4) which is a more viable and progressive social and political philosophy. We find Vygotsky’s classic formulation superior on all counts. This article concerns the politics of language, linguistics, and social theory.

Author: Carl Ratner

View Original Web Page

References :

Adorno, T. (1973/2005). Negative Dialectics, New York: Continuum.

Anyon, J. ( 2011). Marx and Education. NewYork: Routledge.

Anyon, J. (1981). Social class and school knowledge. Curriculum Inquiry 11 (1): 3–42.

Anyon, J. (1980). Social class and the hidden curriculum of work. Journal of Education 162 (1): 67–92.

Apple, M. (1992). Education, culture, and class power: Basil Bernstein and the Neo-Marxist sociology of education. Educational Theory 42 (2): 127–145.

Bacchi, C., and Bonham, J. (2014). Reclaiming discursive practices as an analytic focus: Political implications. Foucault Studies, 17: 173–192. (

Bernstein. B. (1973/1977). Social class, language, and socialization. In J. Karabel, and A. Halsey (Eds), Power and Ideology In Education, 473–486. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bernstein, B. (1975). Class, Codes, and Control, Vol. 3: Towards a Theory of Educational Transmissions. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Bernstein, B. (1977). Class, Codes, and Control, Vol. 3: Towards a Theory of Educational Transmissions. 2nd edition. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Bourdieu, P. (1977). Cultural reproduction and social reproduction. In J. Karabel, and A. Halsey, (Eds), Power and Ideology in Education, 487–511. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bourdieu, P. (1986). The forms of capital. In J. Richardson (Ed.) Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education, 241–258. New York: Greenwood. (

Bourdieu, P. and Passeron, J.-C., (1990). Reproduction in Education, Society and Culture, 2nd edition. London: Sage. (Originally published, 1970.)

Bowles, S., Gintis, H., and Groves, M. (2005). Unequal Changes: Family Background and Economic Success. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Branco, A. and Valsiner, J. (1997). Changing methodologies: A co-constructionist study of goal orientations in social interactions. Psychology and Developing Societies, 9 (1): 35–64.

Braverman, H. (1998). Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the 20th Century. New York: Monthly Review Press.

Castelfranchi, C. (2014). Minds as social institutions. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 13: 121–143.

Daniels, H. (2012). Vygotsky and Sociology. New York: Routledge.

Daniels, H. (2001). Bernstein and Vygotsky: Researching institutional effects in sociocultural theory. In S. Power, P. Aggleton, J. Brannen, A. Brown, L. Chisholm, and J. Mace (Eds), A Tribute to Basil Bernstein 1924–2000. London: Institute of Education.

Foucault, M. (2006). Human nature: Justice versus power. A debate between Noam Chomsky and Michael Foucault. In N. Chomsky and M. Foucault, The Chomsky-Foucault Debate, 1–67. New York: New Press. (Originally debated 1971.)

Foucault, M. (1980). Power/Knowledge. NewYork: Pantheon.

Foucault, M. (1991). Politics and the study of discourse. In G. Burchell, C. Gordon, and P. Miller (Eds), The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality, 53–72. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. (Originally published 1968.)

Freitag, B. (1984). Cognitive and linguistic structures: Bernstein and Piaget in interaction. Archives de Psychologie 52 (202): 153–174.

Gane, N. (2014). The emergence of neoliberalism: Thinking through and beyond Michel Foucault’s Lectures on Biopolitics. Theory, Culture and Society 31: 3–27.

Geertz, C. (1965). The Social History of an Indonesian Town. Boston, MA: MIT Press.

Gonzalez-Rey, F. (2011). The path to subjectivity: Advancing alternative understandings of Vygotsky and the cultural historical legacy. In P. Portes, and S. Salas (Eds), Vygotsky in the 21st Century: Advances in Cultural Historical Theory and Praxis with Non-dominant Communities, 32–49. New York: Peter Lang.

Hymes, D. (1996). Ethnography, Linguistics, Narrative Inequality: Towards an Understanding of Voice. London: Taylor and Francis.

Ilyenkov, E. (2012). Dialectics of the ideal. Historical Materialism, 20 (2): 149–193. (Originally written 1975.)

Jones, P. (2013). Bernstein’s ‘codes’ and the linguistics of ‘deficit’. Language and Education 27 (2): 161–179.

Kantor, J. and Hidgson, S. (2014) Working anything but 9 to 5. New York Times (13 August).

Kurtz, D. (2014). Culture, poverty, politics: Cultural sociologists, Oscar Lewis, Antonio Gramsci. Critique of Anthropolog, 34 (3): 327–345.

Lantolf, J. and Poehner, M. (2014). Sociocultural Theory and the Pedagogical Imperative in L2 Education: Vygotskian Praxis and the Research/Practice Divide. NewYork: Routledge.

Laski, H. (1936). The Rise of Liberalism: The Philosophy of A Business Civilization. New York: Harper.

Lee, J. and Bowen, N. (2006). Parent involvement, cultural capital, and the achievement gap among elementary school children. American Educational Research Journal 43 (2): 193–218.

Leontiev, A. N. (1977). Philosophy in the USSR, Problems of Dialectictical Materialism. Moscow: Progress Publishers. (

Losurdo, D. (2014). Liberalism: A Counter-History. London: Verso.

Luria, A. (1976). Cognitive Development: Its Cultural and Social Foundations. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Madrick, J. (2014). Innovation: The government was crucial after all. New York Review of Books 61 (7): 24 April (

Marcuse, H. (1972). Sartre’s existentialism. In H. Marcuse, Studies in Critical Philosophy, 157–190. Boston, MA: Beacon Press. (Originally published 1948.)

McKenna, B. (2013). Paulo Freire’s blunt challenge to anthropology: Create a Pedagogy of the Oppressed for your times. Critique of Anthropology 33 (1): 447–475.

McNamee, S. J. and Miller, R. K. (2009) The Meritocracy Myth. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Michaels, S., O’Connor, C., and Resnick, L. (2008). Deliberative discourse idealized and realized: Accountable talk in the classroom and in civic life. Studies in Philosophy and Education 27 (4): 283–297.

Michaels, S. (1986). Narrative presentations: An oral preparation for literacy with first graders. In J. Cook-Gumperz (Ed.), The Social Construction of Literacy, 94–116. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Mizen, P. and Ofosu-Kusi, Y. (2013). Agency as vulnerability: accounting for children’s movement to the streets of Accra. Sociological Review 61 (2): 363–382.

Mocombe, P. and Tomlin, C. (2013). Language, Literacy, and Pedagogy in Postindustrial Societies: The Case of Black Academic Underachievement. London: Routledge.

Olfson, M., Blanco, C., Liu, S. M., Wang, S. and Correll, C. U. (2012). National trends in the office-based treatment of children, adolescents, and adults with antipsychotics. Archives of General Psychiatry 69 (12): 1247–1256.

Ratner, C. (1991). Vygotsky’s Sociohistorical Psychology and its Contemporary Applications. New York: Plenum.

Ratner, C. (2000). Agency and culture. Journal for The Theory of Social Behavior 30: 413–434.

Ratner, C. (2002a). Cultural Psychology: Theory and Method. New York: Plenum.

Ratner, C. (2002b). Subjectivity and objectivity in qualitative research. Forum Qualitative Social Research (online journal) 3 (3).

Ratner, C. (2008). Cultural psychology and qualitative methodology: Scientific and political considerations. Culture and Psychology 14 (3): 259–288.

Ratner, C. (2009). Harre’s social philosophy and political philosophy: A social scientific critique. Journal for The Theory of Social Behaviour 39 (4): 448–465.

Ratner, C. (2011). Macro cultural psychology, the psychology of oppression, and cultural-psychological enrichment. In P. Portes and S. Salas (Eds), Vygotsky in 21st Century Society: Advances in Cultural Historical Theory and Praxis with Non-dominant Communities, chapter 5. New York: Peter Lang.

Ratner, C. (2012a). Macro Cultural Psychology: A Political Philosophy Of Mind. New York: Oxford University Press.

Ratner, C. (2012b). Macro cultural psychology: Its development, concerns, politics, and future direction. In M. Gelfand, C. Chiu, Y. Hong (Eds), Advances in Culture and Psychology vol. 3, chapter 6. New York: Oxford University Press.

Ratner, C. (2014a). Cultural-historical psychology and cultural-psychological change. Theory and Critique of Psychology (; available at 

Ratner, C. (2014b). Pathological normalcy: The psychological dimension of alienation and a guiding construct for overcoming alienation. The Humanistic Psychologist 42 (3): 298–303.

Ratner, C. (2015a). Recovering and advancing Martin-Baro’s ideas about psychology, culture, and social transformation. Theory and Critique of Psychology (; available at

Ratner, C. (2015b). Neoliberal Psychology: A Macro Cultural Psychological Analysis. In A. Larrain, A. Haye, M. Morgan, G. Sullivan, & J. Cresswell (Eds), Proceedings of The International Society for Theoretical Psychology. Toronto: Captus Press.

Rogoff, B., Moore, L., Najafi, B. Dexter, A., Correa-Chávez, M. and Solís, J. (2007). Children’s development of cultural repertoires through participation in everyday routines and practices. In J. Grusec and P. Hastings (Eds) Handbook of Socialization: Theory and Research, 490–515. New York: Guilford Press.

Rowe, S., Wertsch, J. and Kosyaeva, T. (2002). Linking little narratives to big ones: Narrative and public memory in history museums. Culture and Psychology 8 (1): 96–112.

Sadovnik, A. (2001). Basil Bernstein. Prospects: The Quarterly Review of Comparative Education. Paris, UNESCO, vol. XXXI, no. 4, December, pp. 687–703:. International Bureau of Education (

Sims-Schouten, W., Riley, S., and Willig, C. (2007). Critical realism in discourse analysis. Theory and Psychology 17 (1): 101–124.

Spackman, J. and Yanchar, S. (2014). Embodied cognition, representationalism, and mechanism: A review and analysis. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 44 (1): 46–79.

Tomlin, C., Mocombe, P., and Wright, C. (2013). Postindustrial capitalism, social class language games, and black underachievement in the United States and United Kingdom. Mind, Culture, and Activity 20 (4): 358–371.

Valsiner, J. (1998). The Guided Mind: A Sociogenetic Approach to Personality. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Valsiner, J. (2009). Cultural psychology today: innovations and oversights. Culture & Psychology 15 (1): 5–39.

Vygotsky, L. S. (1994a). The problem of the environment. In R. Van deer Veer and J. Valsiner (Eds), The Vygotsky Reader, 338–354. Cambridge: Blackwell.

Vygotsky, L. S. (1994b). The socialist alteration of man. In R. Van deer Veer and J. Valsiner (Eds), The Vygotsky Reader, 175–184. Cambridge: Blackwell.

Vygotsky, L.S. (1989). Concrete human psychology. Soviet Psychology: 27 (2): 53–77.

Vygotsky L. S. (1986) Thought and Language. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

Vygotsky, L.S. (1997a). The Collected Works of L. S. Vygotsky, vol. 3. New York: Plenum.

Vygotsky, L. S. (1997b). Educational Psychology. Boca Raton, FL: St. Lucie Press. (Originally published in 1926.)

Vygotsky, L. S. (1925/1971). The Psychology of Art. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Wertsch, J., and Tulviste, P. (2005) L. S. Vygotsky and contemporary developmental psychology. In Harry Daniels (Ed.), An Introduction to Vygotsky, 57–78. London: Psychology Press.

Wertsch, J. (1985a). Vygotsky and the Social Formation of Mind. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Wertsch, J. (1985b). Culture, Communication, and Cognition: Vygotskyian Perspectives. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Wodak, R. (1995). Critical linguistics and critical discourse analysis. In J. Verschueren, J.-O. Östman, and J. Blommaert (Eds), Handbook of Pragmatics, Manual, 204–210. Amsterdam and Philadelphia, PA: John Benjamins Pub Co.