Herding Strategies, Dairy Economy and Seasonal Sites in the Southern Alps: Ethnoarchaeological Inferences and Archaeological Implications
Issue: Vol 28 No. 1 (2015)
Journal: Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology
Subject Areas: Ancient History Archaeology
Abstract:
This paper investigates one of the main issues of the archaeology of pastoralism in the southern Alps: the decrease of upland archaeological evidence in the late Iron Age (IA) and the Roman period. A novel interpretation is proposed using ethnoarchaeological, ethnographic and ethnohistoric data collected in different areas of the French and Italian Alps. These data document the existence of two pastoral strategies: Alpine pastoralism (focused on dairying activity) and transhumance (mainly focused on the exploitation of wool and primary products of livestock). The sites related to the first strategy are usually permanent and complex, while those related to the second are simple and ephemeral. On the basis of this information, the decrease of upland archaeological evidence during the late IA and the Roman period has been interpreted as a consequence of the decrease of dairy activity and increase of transhumance. These inferences allow us to rethink the evolution of human exploitation of high mountain environments, as well as to tackle the bias of archaeological invisibility in specific pastoral contexts. Furthermore, they also confirm the important role of ethnoarchaeology as a method of improving archaeological interpretation.
Author: Francesco Carrer
References :
Aime, M., S. Allovio and P.P. Viazzo 2001 Sapersi muovere: Pastori transumanti di Roaschia. Rome: Meltemi.
Arbos, P. 1922 La Vie Pastorale dans les Alpes Françaises: Étude de Géographie Humaine. Paris: Armand Colin.
Bagatella Seno, A. 1982 Tecniche tradizionali di allevamento e cura del gregge. In D. Perco (ed.), La pastorizia transumante del feltrino. Comunità Montana Feltrina, Centro per la Documentazione della Cultura Popolare, Quaderno 3: 39-62. Feltre, Italy: Comunità Montana Feltrina.
Bagolini, B., and A. Pedrotti 1992 Vorgeschichtliche Höhenfunde im Trentino-Südtirol und im Dolomitenraum vom Spätpaläolothikum bis zu den Anfängen der Metallurgie. In F. Höpfel, W. Platzer and K. Spindler (eds.), Der Mann im Eis 1. Bericht über das Internationale Symposium 1992. Veröffentlichungen der Universität Innsbruck 187: 359-77. Innsbruck, Austria: Eigenverlag der Universität Innsbruck.
Barker, G. 1999 Hunting and farming in prehistoric Italy: changing perspectives on landscape and society. Papers of the British School at Rome 67: 1-36. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0068246200004517
Barker, G., and A. Grant 1991 Ancient and modern farming in prehistoric Italy: an interdisciplinary study in the Cicolano mountains. Papers of the British School at Rome 59: 15-88. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0068246200009673
Biagi, P. 2002 Le stazioni preistoriche del Monte Guglielmo (Gölem) e del Monte Ario in Val Trompia (Brescia). In Commentari dell’Ateneo di Brescia per l’anno 2002 bicentenario di fondazione. Atti della Fondazione ‘Ugo da Como’ 201: 223-49. Brescia, Italy: Ateneo di Brescia.
Blanchard, R. 1950 Les Alpes Occidentales V. Les Grandes Alpes françaises du Sud. Grenoble and Paris, France: B. Arthaud.
Bonetto, J. 1997 Le vie armentarie tra Patavium e la montagna. Padova, Italy: Provincia di Padova.
Busana, M.S., P. Basso, A.R. Tricomi and S. Pesavento Mattioli (eds.) 2012 La lana nella Cisalpina romana: economia e società. Studi in onore di Stefania Pesavento Mattioli: Atti del convegno Padova-Verona, 18-20 maggio 2011. Antenor Quaderni 27. Padova, Italy: Padova University Press.
Carrer, F. 2013 Archeologia della pastorizia nelle Alpi: nuovi dati e vecchi dubbi. Preistoria Alpina 47: 17-30.
Cavada, E. 1992 L’iscrizione confinaria del Monte Pèrgol in Val Cadino nel Trentino orientale. In L. Gasperini (ed.), Rupes Loquentes: Atti del Convegno Internazionale di Studio sulle Iscrizioni Rupestri di Età Romana in Italia, Roma-Bomarzo 13-15. X. 1989, 99-115. Rome: Istituto Italiano per la Storia Antica.
Cavada, E. 1999 Quale presenza umana nelle valli dolomitico-ladine dall’età romana all’altomedioevo? In N. Valeruz and F. Chiocchetti (eds.), L’entità ladina dolomitica: etnogenesi e Identità. Atti del Convegno Interdisciplinare, Vigo di Fassa, 11-14 settembre 1996, Mondo Ladino, Bolatin de l’Istitut Cultural Ladin 22: 169-215. Vigo di Fassa, Italy: Istitut Cultural Ladin.
Chang, C., and H.A. Koster 1986 Beyond bones: toward an archaeology of pastoralism. In M.B. Schiffer (ed.), Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory 9: 97-148. London: Academic Press.
Cleary, M.C. 1987 Transhumance in Languedoc and Provence. Geografiska Annaler. Series B, Human Geography 69: 107-13. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/490444
Cleary, M.C., and C. Delano Smith 1992 Transhumance reviewed: past and present practices in France and Italy. In R. Maggi, R. Nisbet and G. Barker (eds.), Archeologia della pastorizia nell’Europa meridionale: Atti della Tavola Rotonda Internazionale, Chiavari, 22-24 settembre 1989. Rivista di Studi Liguri 56: 1-4. Bordighera, Italy: Istituto Internazionale di Studi Liguri.
Corti, M. 2004 Süssura de l aalp: il sistema dell’alpeggio nelle Alpi lombarde. In G. Kezich and P.P. Viazzo (eds.), Il destino delle malghe: trasformazioni nello spazio alpino e scenari futuribili di un sistema di consuetudini d’alpeggio: Atti di SPEA7 Seminario Permanente di Etnografia Alpina—7° ciclo 2002. SM Annali di San Michele 17: 31-155. San Michele all’Adige, Italy: Museo degli Usi e Costumi della Gente Trentina.
Cresci Marrone, G., and M. Tirelli 2003 Altino da porto dei veneti a mercato romano. In G. Cresci Marrone and M. Tirelli (eds.), Produzioni, merci e commerci in Altino preromana e romana: Atti del III Convegno di Studi Altinati (Venezia, 12-14 dicembre 2001), 7-25. Rome: Quasar.
Cribb, R. 1991 Nomads in Archaeology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
David, N., and C. Kramer 2001 Ethnoarchaeology in Action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Davies, E. 1941 The patterns of transhumance in Europe. Geography 26(4): 155-68.
Fabre, P., and G. Lebaudy (eds.) 2002 1951. Transhumance sur la route des alpages. Saint-Martin-de-Crau, France: Maison de la Transhumance.
Fedele, F., and L. Wick 1996 Glacial/postglacial transition south of Splügen Pass: environmental and human activity. Il Quaternario 9: 541-50.
Forbes, H. 1995 The identification of pastoralist sites within the context of estate-based agriculture in ancient Greece: beyond the ‘Transhumance versos Agro-Pastoralism’ debate. Annual of the British School at Athens 90: 325-38.
Gabba, E., and M. Pasquinucci 1979 Strutture agrarie e allevamento transumante nell’Italia romana (III-I sec. a.C.). Pisa: Giardini Editori.
Garcia D., F. Mocci, S. Tzortzis and K. Walsh 2007 Archéologie de la vallée de l’Ubaye (Alpe-de-Haute-Provence, France): premiers résultats d’un Project Collectif de Recherche. In P. Della Casa and K. Walsh (eds.), Interpretation of Sites and Material Culture from Mid-High Altitude mountain Environments: Proceedings of the 10th Annual Meeting of the European Association of Archaeologists 2004. Preistoria Alpina 42: 23-48. Trento, Italy: Museo Tridentino di Scienze Naturali.
Gould, R.A., and P.J. Watson 1982 A dialogue on the meaning and use of analogy in ethnoarchaeological reasoning. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 1: 355-81.
Greenfield, H.J. 2010 The Secondary Products Revolution: the past, the present and the future. World Archaeology 42: 29-54.
Grosjean, M., P.J. Suter, M. Trachsel and H. Wanner 2007 Ice-borne prehistoric finds in the Swiss Alps reflect Holocene glacier fluctuations. Journal of Quaternary Science 22: 203-207.
Halstead, P. 1996 Pastoralism or household herding? Problems of scale and specialization in early Greek animal husbandry. World Archaeology 28: 20-42.
Jospin, J.-P., and L. Favrie (eds.) 2008 Premiers Bergers des Alpes: De la préhistoire à l’Antiquité. Isère, France: Infolio.
Jospin, L.-P., and L. Venditelli 2008 Un domaine pastoral en Chartreuse: celui des Avei. In J.-P. Jospin and T. Favrie (eds.), Premiers Bergers des Alpes: De la préhistoire à l’Antiquité, 137-38. Isère, France: Infolio.
Khazanov, A.M. 1984 Nomads and the Outside World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Leguilloux, M. 2003 Les bergeries de la Crau: production et commerce de la laine. Revue Archéologique de Picardie 1-2: 339-46. http://dx.doi.org/10.3406/pica.2003.2376
Leveau, P. 2006 Entre la plaine de la Crau et le massif des Écrins, la question du pastoralisme romain. In C. Jourdain-Annequin and J.-C. Duclos (eds.), Aux origines de la Transhumance: Les Alpes et la vie pastorale d’hier à aujourd’hui, 205-21. Paris: Picard.
Leveau, P. 2012 Transhumances, remues et migrations des troupeaux dans les Alpes et les Pyrénées antiques: la question du pastoralisme romain. In L. Callegarin and F. Réchin (eds.), Espaces et sociétés à l’époque romaine: entre Gronne et Ébre: Actes de la Table Ronde de Pau, 26-27 janvier 2007. Hommage à Georges Fabre. Archéologie des Pyrénées Occidentales et des Landes 4: 142-74. Pau, France: Université de Pau et des Pays de l’Adour.
Leveau, P., and M. Segard 2004 Le pastoralisme en Gaule du sud entre plaine et montagne: de la Crau aux Alpes du sud. Pallas 64: 99-113.
Lyman, R.L., and M.J. O’Brien 2001 The direct historical approach, analogical reasoning, and theory in Americanist archaeology. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 8: 303-42. http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/A:1013736416067
Marzatico, F. 2007 La frequentazione dell’ambiente montano nel territorio atesino fra l’età del Bronzo e del Ferro: alcune considerazioni sulla pastorizia transumante e ‘l’economia di malga’. In P. Della Casa and K. Walsh (eds.), Interpretation of Sites and Material Culture from Mid-High Altitude Mountain Environments: Proceedings of the 10th Annual Meeting of the European Association of Archaeologists 2004. Preistoria Alpina 42: 163-82. Trento, Italy: Museo Tridentino di Scienze Naturali.
McClure, S.B., M.A. Jochim and M. Barton 2006 Human behavioral ecology, domestic animals, and land use during the transition to agriculture in Valencia, eastern Spain. In D.J. Kennett and B. Winterhalder (eds.), Behavioral Ecology and the Transition to Agriculture, 197-216. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Mientjes, A.C. 2008 Paesaggi Pastorali: Studio etnoarcheologico sul pastoralismo in Sardegna. Cagliari, Italy: Cooperativa Universitaria Editrice Cagliaritana.
Migliario, E. 2002 Confini di comunità e comunità di confine di area alpina centro-orientale in età romana. Archeologia delle Alpi 6: 57-74.
Migliavacca, M. 1985 Pastorizia e uso del territorio nel vicentino e nel veronese nell’età del Bronzo e del Ferro. Archeologia Veneta 8: 27-60.
Migliorini, E. 1932 La Val Belluna: Studio antropogeografico. Rome: Istituto di Geografia della Regia Università di Roma.
Moe, D., F. Fedele, A. Engan Maude and M. Kvamme 2007 Vegetation changes and human presence in the low alpine and subalpine zone in Val Febbraro, upper Valle Spluga (Italian central Alps), from the Neolithic to the Roman period. Vegetation History and Archaeobotany 16: 431-51. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00334-006-0088-0
Morin, A., and R. Picavet 2006 Archéologie et pastoralisme d’altitude (Vercors, Dévoluy, haute vallée du Buëch). In C. Jourdain-Annequin and J.-C. Duclos (eds.), Aux origines de la transhumance, les Alpes et la vie pastorale d’hier à aujourd’hui, 187-203. Paris: Édition Picard.
Mottes, E., and F. Nicolis 2004 Storo–Dosso Rotondo (Trento): un sito di alta quota dell’età del Bronzo in Valle del Chiese. Annali del Museo 19: 79-88. Gavardo, Italy: Civico Museo Archeologico della Val Sabbia.
Nangeroni, G., and R. Pracchi 1958 La casa rurale nella montagna lombarda I-II. Florence, Italy: Olschki.
Nequirito, M. 2002 A norma di regola: le comunità di villaggio trentine dal medioevo alla fine del ‘700. Trento, Italy: Provincia Autonoma di Trento.
Netting, R. McC. 1976 What Alpine peasants have in common: observation on communal tenure in a Swiss village. Human Ecology 4: 135-46. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF01531217
Nisbet, R., and D. Seglie (eds.) 1983 Balm’Chanto: Archeologia della Val Chisone. Pinerolo, Italy: Centro Studi e Museo d’Arte Preistorica.
O’Connell, J. 1995 Ethnoarchaeology needs a general theory of behavior. Journal of Archaeological Research 3: 205-55. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF02231450
Orme, B. 1981 Anthropology for Archaeologists: An Introduction. London: Routledge.
Pascolini, M. 2001 L’alpeggio nelle Alpi orientali: modelli storici e situazione attuale. In P.P. Viazzo and E. Wolf (eds.), L’alpeggio e il mercato. La Ricerca Folklorica 43: 71-81. Brescia, Italy: Grafo.
Perco, D. 1982 L’organizzazione sociale e del lavoro: la cultura dei pastori lamonesi. In D. Perco (ed.), La pastorizia transumante del feltrino. Comunità Montana Feltrina, Centro per la Documentazione della Cultura Popolare 3: 69-98. Feltre, Italy: Comunità Montana Feltrina.
Pracchi, R. 1942 Il fenomeno della transumanza sul versante italiano delle Alpi. Como, Italy: Marzorati.
Primas, M. 1999 From fiction to facts: current research on prehistoric human activity in the Alps. In P. Della Casa (ed.), Prehistoric Alpine Environment, Society and Economy: Papers of the International Colloquium PAESE ‘97. Universitäts-forschungen zur Archäologie 55: 1-10. Zürich, Switzerland: Rudolf Habelt.
Remacle, C. 2001 Evoluzione dell’architettura degli alpeggi in Valle d’Aosta (XVIII-XIX secolo). In P.P. Viazzo and E. Wolf (eds.), L’alpeggio e il mercato. La Ricerca Folklorica 43: 55-61. Brescia, Italy: Grafo.
Rosada, G. 2004 Altino e la via della transumanza nella Venetia centrale. In PECUS, Man and Animal in Antiquity: Proceedings of the Conference at the Swedish Institute in Rome, September 9-12 2002, 67-79. Rome: Swedish Institute in Rome.
Rosenberg, H.G. 1988 A Negotiated World: Three Centuries of Change in a French Alpine Community. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Salque, M., P.I. Bogucki, J. Pyzel, I. Sobkowiak-Tabaka, R. Grygiel, M. Szmyt and R.P. Evershed 2012 Earliest evidence for cheese making in the sixth millennium bc in northern Europe. Nature 493: 522-25. http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature11698
Sánchez Moreno, E. 1998 De ganados, movimientos y contactos: revisando la cuestión trashumante en la protohistoria hispana: la meseta occidental. Studia Historica, Historia Antigua 16: 53-84.
Scheuermeier, P. 1943 Bauernwerk in Italien, der italienischen und rätoromanischen Schweiz, I. Erlenbach-Zürich, Switzerland: Rentsch.
Šebesta, G. 1991 La via delle malghe. In G. Šebesta (ed.), Scritti Etnografici, 466-500. San Michele all’Adige, Italy: Museo degli Usi e Costumi della Gente Trentina.
Segard, M. 2009 Pastoralism, rural economy and landscape evolution in the western Alps. Journal of Roman Archaeology 22: 171-82.
Sherratt, A. 1983 The secondary exploitation of animals in the Old World. World Archaeology 15: 90-104. 1997 Wool, wheels and ploughmarks: local developments or outside introduction in neolithic Europe? In A. Sherratt, Economy and Society in Prehistoric Europe: Changing Perspectives, 229-41. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Skibo, J.M. 2009 Archaeological theory and snake-oil peddling: the role of ethnoarchaeology in archaeology. Ethnoarchaeology 1: 27-56. http://dx.doi.org/10.1179/eth.2009.1.1.27
Solano, S. 2010 L’iscrizione di Roncone (Trento) nel quadro dell’epigrafia preromana in alta quota fra area retica e camuna. Notizie Archeologiche Bergomensi 18: 155-64.
Spangenberg, J.E., S. Jacomet and J. Schibler 2006 Chemical analyses of organic residues in archaeological pottery from Arbon Bleiche 3, Switzerland—evidence for dairying in the late Neolithic. Journal of Archaeological Science 33: 1-13. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2005.05.013
Valvo, A. 1992 Iscrizioni rupestri di età romana in Valcamonica e Valtellina. In L. Gasperini (ed.), Rupes Loquentes: Atti del Convegno Internazionale di Studio sulle Iscrizioni Rupestri di Età Romana in Italia, Roma-Bomarzo 13-15. X. 1989, 49-88. Rome: Istituto Italiano per la Storia Antica.
Viazzo, P.P., and Wolf, E. (eds.) 2001 L’alpeggio e il mercato. La Ricerca Folklorica 43. Brescia, Italy: Grafo.
Walsh, K. 2005 Risk and marginality at high altitudes: new interpretations from fieldwork on the Faravel Plateau, Hautes-Alpes. Antiquity 79: 289-305.
Walsh, K. 2013 The Archaeology of Mediterranean Landscapes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139024921
Walsh, K., M. Court-Picon, J.-L. de Beaulieu, F. Guiter, F. Mocci, S. Richer, R. Sinet, B. Talon and S. Tzortzis 2014 A historical ecology of the Ecrins (southern French Alps): archaeology and palaeoecology of the Mesolithic to the Medieval period. Quaternary International 353: 52-73. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.quaint.2013.08.060
Walsh, K., and F. Mocci 2011 Mobility in the mountains: late third and second millennia Alpine societies’ engagements with high-altitude zones in the Southern French Alps. European Journal of Archaeology 14: 88-115. http://dx.doi.org/10.1179/146195711798369427
Walsh, K., F. Mocci, M. Court-Picon, S. Tzortzis and J.-M. Palet-Martinez 2005 Dynamique du peuplement et activités agro-pastorales durant l’âge du Bronze dans le massif du Haut Champsaur et de l’Argentierois (Hautes-Alpes). Documents d’Archéologie méridionale 28: 25-44.
Walsh, K., F. Mocci and J. Palet-Martinez 2007 Nine thousand years of human/landscape dynamics in a high altitude zone in the southern French Alps. In P. Della Casa and K. Walsh (eds.), Interpretation of Sites and Material Culture from Mid-High Altitude Mountain Environments: Proceedings of the 10th Annual Meeting of the European Association of Archaeologists 2004. Preistoria Alpina 42: 9-22. Trento, Italy: Museo Tridentino di Scienze Naturali.
Walsh, K., S. Richer and J.-L. de Baulieu 2006 Attitudes to altitude: changing meanings and perceptions within a ‘marginal’ Alpine landscape—the integration of palaeoecological and archaeological data in a high-altitude landscape in the French Alps. World Archaeology 38: 436-54. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00438240600813392