Item Details

A New Era in the Study of Global History Is Born but It Needs to Be Nurtured

Issue: Vol 5 No. 1-2 (2018)

Journal: Journal of Cognitive Historiography

Subject Areas: Ancient History Cognitive Studies Archaeology

DOI: 10.1558/jch.39422

Abstract:

This article is a response to Slingerland et al. who criticize the quality of the data from Seshat: Global History Databank utilized in our Nature paper entitled “Complex Societies Precede Moralizing Gods throughout World History”. Their critique centres around the roles played by research assistants and experts in procuring and curating data, periodization structure, and so-called “data pasting” and “data filling”. We show that these criticisms are based on misunderstandings or misrepresentations of the methods used by Seshat researchers. Overall, Slingerland et al.’s critique (which is crosslinked online here) does not call into question any of our main findings, but it does highlight various shortcomings of Slingerland et al.’s database project. Our collective efforts to code and quantify features of global history hold out the promise of a new era in the study of global history but only if critique can be conducted constructively in good faith and both the benefits and the pitfalls of open science fully recognized.

Author: Harvey Whitehouse, Peter Turchin, Pieter Fran├žois, Patrick E. Savage, Thomas E. Currie, Kevin C. Feeney, Enrico Cioni, Rosalind Purcell, Robert M. Ross, Jennifer Larson, John Baines, Barend ter Haar, R. Alan Covey

View Full Text

References :

Beheim, B., Q. Atkinson, J. Bulbulia, W. Gervais, R. D. Gray, J. Henrich, M. Lang, et al. 2019. “Corrected Analyses Show That Moralizing Gods Precede Complex Societies but Serious Data Concerns Remain.” Preprint:  https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/jwa2n.

Bagley, R. 1999. “Shang archaeology.” In The Cambridge History of Ancient China: From the Origins of Civilization to 221 BC, ed. M. Loewe and E. L. Shaughnessy, 124–231. Cambridge University Press.

Cho-yun, Hsu and K. M. Linduff. 1988. Early Chinese Civilization Series. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 376. 

Cornell, T. J. 1995. The beginnings of Rome: Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000-264 BC). London: Routledge.

Forsythe, G. 2006. A critical history of early Rome from Prehistory to the First Punic War. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Keay, J. 2009. China, A History. London, HarperPress. 

Levine, J., J. Larson, J. Baines, V. Wallace, and B. ter Haar. 2017. “Experts Reflect on Their Experiences Working with Seshat: Global History Databank.” Seshat: Global History Databank Blog. http://seshatdatabank.info/expert_reflections.

Peregrine, P. N., R. Brennan, T. Currie, K. Feeney, P. François, P. Turchin, and H. Whitehouse. 2018. “Dacura: A new solution to data harvesting and knowledge extraction for the historical sciences.” Historical Methods: A Journal of Quantitative and Interdisciplinary History. doi:10.1080/01615440.2018.1443863
Savage, P. E., H. Whitehouse, P. François, T. E. Currie, K. C. Feeney, E. Cioni, R. Purcell, et al. Under review. “Reply to Beheim et al.: Reanalyses confirm robustness of original analyses.” PsyArXiv preprint (doi forthcoming).
Slingerland, E.  and B. Sullivan, 2017. “Durkheim with Data: The Database of Religious History.” Journal of the American Academy of Religion, 85 (2): 312–347. https://doi.org/10.1093/jaarel/lfw012

Slingerland, E., W. Monroe, B. Sullivan, R. Faith Walsh, D. Veidlinger, W. Noseworthy, C. Herriott, et al. 2019. “Historians Respond to ‘Complex Societies Precede Moralizing Gods throughout World History.’” Journal of Cognitive Historiography. Preprint: https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/2amjz.
Thorp, R. L. 2006. Encounters with Asia: China in the Early Bronze Age: Shang Civilization. University of Pennsylvania Press: Philadelphia, 181. 
Turchin, P., R. Brennan, T. E. Currie, K. C. Feeney, P. François, D. Hoyer, J. G. Manning, A. Marciniak, D. Mullins, A. Palmisano, P. Peregrine, E. A. L. Turner, and H. Whitehouse (2015). Seshat: The Global History Databank. Cliodynamics: The Journal of Quantitative History and Cultural Evolution 6(1): 77-107. http://escholarship.org/uc/item/9qx38718

Turchin, P., T. E. Currie, H. Whitehouse, P. François, K. Feeney, D. Mullins, D. Hoyer, et al. 2018. “Quantitative Historical Analysis Uncovers a Single Dimension of Complexity That Structures Global Variation in Human Social Organization.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 115 (2): E144–51. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1708800115.

Turchin, P., H. Whitehouse, P. François, et al. 2019. “An Introduction to Seshat: Global History Databank”. Journal of Cognitive Historiography.

Wang, H. 2014. Writing and the Ancient State: Early China in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge University Press.

Whitehouse, H., P. François, P. E. Savage, T. E. Currie, K. C. Feeney, E. Cioni, R. Purcell, et al. 2019. “Complex Societies Precede Moralizing Gods throughout World History.” Nature 568 (7751): 226-229. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-019-1043-4.
Zhu, X. (Translated by P. B. Ebrey) 1991. Chu Hsi's family rituals: a twelfth-century Chinese manual for the performance of cappings, weddings, funerals, and ancestral rites. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 153-4.