Process-Oriented Writing Instruction in Elementary Classrooms: Evidence of Effective Practices from the Research Literature
Issue: Vol 6 No. 3 (2014)
Journal: Writing & Pedagogy
Process writing instruction is an influential paradigm in elementary classrooms, but studies of its effectiveness are mixed. These mixed results may occur because teachers implement process writing in vastly difference ways, which makes it difficult to assess the effectiveness of process approaches broadly. Therefore, this literature review examines the features of the process writing instruction are effective. Drawing on empirical evidence, it answers the question: What practices within process writing have evidence of effectiveness? A literature search was conducted and 93 studies that met the inclusion criteria were found. The studies were coded thematically and indicate seven categories of effective practices: writing strategy instruction, computers in the writing process, talk during the writing process, play during the writing process, including children’s ways of knowing, flexible participation structures, and mentor texts. Evidence about the effectiveness of these features and directions for future research are discussed.
Author: Vicki McQuitty
Andrzejczak, N., Trainin, G. and Poldberg, M. (2005) From image to text: Using
images in the writing process. International Journal of Education and the Arts
6: 1–16. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.ijea.org/v6n12/v6n12.pdf.
Applebee, A. N. and Langer, J. A. (2006) The State of Writing Instruction in
America’s Schools: What Existing Data Tell Us. Albany, New York: Center on
English Learning and Achievement.
Baines, L., Baines, C., Stanley, G. K. and Kunkel, A. (1999) Losing product in the
process. English Journal 88: 67–72. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://
Bereiter, C., and Scardamalia, M. (1987) The Psychology of Written Composition.
Hillsdale, New Jersey: Erlbaum.
Blain, S. (2001) Study of verbal peer feedback on the improvement of the quality
of writing and the transfer of knowledge in Francophone students in Grade 4
living in a minority situation in Canada. Language, Culture, and Curriculum
14(2): 156–170. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/07908310108666619.
Bogard, J. M. and McMackin, M. C. (2012) Combining traditional and new
literacies in a 21st-century writing workshop. The Reading Teacher 65:
313–323. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/TRTR .01048.
Bomer, R. and Laman, T. T. (2004) Positioning in a primary writing workshop:
Joint action in the discursive production of writing subjects. Research in the
Teaching of English 38: 420–466. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.
Brown, S. (2009) Navigating an English-only classroom: Multiple identities in
a primary writer’s workshop. Journal of Classroom Interaction 44: 29–38.
Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.jciuh.org/issues/vol44no1.
Burns, T. J. (2001) Being “social”: Expanding our view of social interaction in
writing workshops. Language Arts 78: 458–466. Retrieved on 1 March 2012
Calkins, L. M. (1994) The Art of Teaching Writing. Portsmouth, New Hampshire:
Christianakis, M. (2010) “I don’t need your help!”: Peer status, race, and gender
during peer writing interactions. Journal of Literacy Research 42: 418–458.
Christie, F., Martin, J. R. and Rothery, J. (1989) Genres making meaning: Another
reply to Sawyer and Watson. English in Australia 90: 43–59. Retrieved on 2
March 2012 from http://www.aate.org.au/view_journal.php?id=29.
Corbin, J., and Strauss, A. L. (2007). Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques
and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory (3rd edition). Thousand Oaks,
California: Sage Publications.
Corden, R. (2007) Developing reading–writing connections: The impact of
explicit instruction of literary devices on the quality of children’s narrative
writing. Journal of Research in Childhood Education 21: 269–289. http://
The Council of Chief State School Officers and National Governers Association
(2010) Common core state standards for English language arts and literacy
in history/social studies, science, and technical subjects. Retrieved on 6
September 2011 from www.corestandards.org.
Culham, R. (2003) 6+1 Traits of Writing. New York: Scholastic.
Cutler, L. and Graham, S. (2008) Primary grade writing instruction: A national
survey. Journal of Educational Psychology 100: 907–919. http://dx.doi.
Daiute, C. and Dalton, B. (1993) Collaboration between children learning to
write: Can novices be masters? Cognition and Instruction 10(4): 281–333.
Danoff, B., Harris, K. R. and Graham, S. (1993) Incorporating strategy instruction
within the writing process in the regular classroom: Effects on the writing of
students with and without learning disabilities. Journal of Reading Behavior 25:
Delpit, L. (1988) The silenced dialogue: Power and pedagogy in educating other
people’s children. Harvard Educational Review 58(3): 280–298. Retrieved on 1
March 2012 from http://her.hepg.org/content/c43481778r528qw4/?p=46a54ee
Dressel, J. H. (1990) The effects of listening to and discussing different qualities
of children’s literature on the narrative writing of fifth graders. Research in the
Teaching of English 24: 397–414. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.
Dutro, E., Kazemi, E. and Balf, R. (2006) Making sense of “the boy who died”:
Tales of a struggling successful writer. Reading and Writing Quarterly 22:
Dyson, A. H. (1992) The case of the singing scientist: A performance perspective
on the “stages” of school literacy. Written Communication 9: 3–47. http://
Dyson, A. H. (1993) From invention to social action in early childhood
literacy: A reconceptualization through dialogue about difference. Early
Childhood Research Quarterly 8: 409–425. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/
Dyson, A. H. (2001) Donkey Kong in Little Bear country: A first grader’s composing
development in the media spotlight. Elementary School Journal 101: 417–494.
Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.jstor.org/stable/1002127.
Dyson, A. H. (2003) “Welcome to the Jam”: Popular culture, school literacy,
and the making of childhoods. Harvard Educational Review 73: 328–361.
Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://hepg.org/her/abstract/76.
Dyson, A. H. (2008a) The pine cone wars: Studying writing in a community of
children. Language Arts 85: 305–315. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/07410883920
Dyson, A. H. (2008b) Staying in the (curricular) lines: Practice constraints and
possibilities in childhood writing. Written Communication 25: 119–159.
Edwards-Groves, C. J. (2011) The multimodal writing process: Changing
practices in contemporary classrooms. Language and Education 25: 49–64.
Englert, C. S., Raphael, T., Anderson, L. M., Anthony, H. M. and Stevens, D. D.
(1991) Making strategies and self-talk visible: Writing instruction in regular
and special education classrooms. American Educational Research Journal 28:
Enns, C., Hall, R., Isaac, B. and MacDonald, P. (2007) Process and product:
Creating stories with deaf students. TESL Canada Journal 25: 1–22. Retrieved
on 1 March 2012 from http://www.teslcanadajournal.ca/index.php/tesl/article/
Fitzgerald, J. and Stamm, C. (1990) Effects of group conferences on first graders’
revision in writing. Written Communication 7: 96–135. http://dx.doi.org/10.11
Fu, D. and Shelton, N. (2007) Including students with special needs in a writing
workshop. Language Arts 84: 325–336. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from
Gilbert, J. and Graham, S. (2010) Teaching writing to elementary students in
grades 4–6: A national survey. Elementary School Journal 110: 494–518.
Glaser, B. G. and Strauss, A. L. (1967) The Discovery of Grounded Theory:
Strategies for Qualitative Research. Hawthorne, New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
Gort, M. (2006) Strategic codeswitching, interliteracy, and other phenomena
of emergent bilingual writing: Lessons from first grade dual language
classrooms. Journal of Early Childhood Literacy 6: 323–354. http://dx.doi.
Graham, S. (2006) Strategy instruction and the teaching of writing: A metaanalysis.
In C. A. MacArthur, S. Graham and J. Fitzgerald (eds.) Handbook of
Research on Writing 187–207. New York: Guilford Press.
Graham, S. and Sandmel, K. (2011) The process writing approach: A metaanalysis.
Journal of Educational Research. 104: 396–407. http://dx.doi.org/10.1
Hachem, A., Nabhani, M. and Bahous, R. (2008) “We can write!” The writing
workshop for young learners. Education 36: 325–337. http://dx.doi.
Harper, C., Platt, E., Naranjo, C., and Boynton, S. (2007) Marching in unison:
Florida ESL teachers and No Child Left Behind. TESOL Quarterly 41:
Harris, K. R. and Graham, S. (1996) Making the Writing Process Work: Strategies
for Composition and Self-Regulation. Brookline, Massachusetts: Brookline
Harris, K. R., Graham, S. and Mason, L. H. (2006) Improving the writing,
knowledge, and motivation of struggling young writers: Effects of
self-regulated strategy development with and without peer support.
American Educational Research Journal 43: 295–337. http://dx.doi.
Hawkins, L. K. and Razali, A. B. (2012) A tale of 3 P’s – Penmanship, product,
and process: 100 years of elementary writing instruction. Language Arts 89:
305–317. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.ncte.org/journals/la/
Hillocks, G. (1986) Research on Written Composition: New Directions
for Teaching. Urbana, Illinois: ERIC Clearinghouse on Reading and
Communication Skills and National Conference on Research in English.
Hoewisch, A. (2001) “Do I have to have a princess in my story?”: Supporting
children’s writing of fairytales. Reading and Writing Quarterly 17: 249–277.
Huxford, L. (2004) Developing an understanding of the pedagogy of writing in
the middle years (age 8–11). Australian Journal of Language and Literacy 27:
Jasmine, J. and Weiner, W. (2007) The effects of writing workshop on abilities
of first grade students to become confident and independent writers. Early
Childhood Education Journal 35: 131–139. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/
Jones, I. (1994) The effect of a word processor on the written composition of
second-grade pupils. Computers in the Schools 11: 43–53. http://dx.doi.
Jones, I. and Pellegrini, A. D. (1996) The effects of social relationships, writing
media, and microgenetic development on first grade students’ written
narratives. American Educational Research Journal 33: 691–718. http://dx.doi.
Kara-Soteriou, J. and Kaufman, D. (2002) Writing in the elementary school:
The missing pieces. The New England Reading Association Journal 38(3):
25–33. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.highbeam.com/
Kindzierski, C. M. (2009) “I like it the way it is!”: Peer-revision writing strategies
for students with emotional and behavioral disorders. Preventing School
Failure 54: 51–59. http://dx.doi.org/10.3200/PSFL.54.1.51-59.
Kress, G. (1999) Genre and the changing contexts for English language arts.
Language Arts 76: 461–469. Retrieved on 1 March from http://www.ncte.org/
Kuhlman, W. D., Danielson, K. E., Campbell, E. I. and Topp, N. W. (2005)
Implementing handheld computers as tools for first-grade writers. Computers
in the Schools 22: 173–185. http://dx.doi.org/10.1300/J025v22n03-14.
Labbo, L. D., Hoffman, J. and Roser, N. (1995) Ways to unintentionally make
writing difficult. Language Arts 72: 164–170. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from
Laman, T. T. (2011) The functions of talk within a 4th-grade writing workshop:
Insights into understanding. Journal of Research in Childhood Education 25:
Laman, T. T. and Van Sluys, K. (2008) Being and becoming: Multilingual writers’
practices. Language Arts 85: 265–274. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://
Larson, J. (1999) Analyzing participation frameworks in kindergarten writing
activity: The role of overhearer in learning to write. Written Communication
16: 225–257. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0741088399016002004.
Larson, J. and Maier, M. (2000) Co-authoring classroom texts: Shifting participant
roles in writing activity. Research in the Teaching of English 34: 468–497.
Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.ncte.org/journals/rte/issues/v34-4.
Lensmire, T. (1994) Writing workshop as carnival: Reflections on an alternative
learning environment. Harvard Educational Review 64: 371–391. Retrieved on
1 March 2012 from http://hepg.org/her/abstract/340.
Lewison, M. and Heffernan, L. (2008) Rewriting writers workshop: Creating safe
spaces for disruptive stories. Research in the Teaching of English 42: 435–465.
Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.ncte.org/journals/rte/issues/v42-4.
Lorenz, B., Green, T. and Brown, A. (2009) Using multimedia graphic organizer
software in the prewriting activities of primary school students: What
are the benefits? Computers in the Schools 26: 115–129. http://dx.doi.
Lysaker, J. T., Wheat, J. and Benson, E. (2010) Children’s spontaneous play in
writer’s workshop. Journal of Early Childhood Literacy 10: 209–229. http://
MacArthur, C. A., Graham, S., and Fitzgerald, J. (2006). Handbook of Writing
Research. New York: Guildford Press.
MacArthur, C. A., Schwartz, S. S., Graham, S., Molloy, D. and Harris, K. R.
(1996) Integration of strategy instruction into a whole language classroom:
A case study. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice 11: 168–176.
Mackenzie, N. (2011) From drawing to writing: What happens when you shift
teaching priorities in the first six months of school? Australian Journal of
Language and Literacy 34: 322–340. http://www.alea.edu.au/resources/
Manak, J. (2009) The impact of Pam Munoz Ryan’s Mice and Beans on young writers.
Journal of Children’s Literature 35: 23–31. http://www.childrensliteratureassembly.
Martin, J. R. (1985) Factual Writing: Exploring and Challenging Social Reality.
Oxford: Oxford University Press.
McCarthey, S. J. (1994) Authors, text, and talk: The internalization of dialogue
from social interaction during writing. Reading Research Quarterly 29: 200
McCarthey, S. J. (2008) The impact of No Child Left Behind on teachers’
writing instruction. Written Communication 25: 462–505. http://dx.doi.
Morocco, C. C., Dalton, B. and Tivnan, T. (1992) The impact of computersupported
writing instruction on fourth-grade students with and without
learning disabilities. Reading and Writing Quarterly 8: 87–113. http://dx.doi.
Murray, D. (1985). A Writer Teaches Writing (2nd editions). Boston: Houghton
Myhill, D. and Jones, S. (2009) How talk becomes text: Investigating the concept
of oral rehearsal in early years’ classrooms. British Journal of Educational
Studies 53: 265–284. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8527.2009.00438.x.
National Commission on Writing (2003) The Neglected “R”: The Need for a
Writing Revolution. Washington, D. C.: College Board.
Nazarenko, L. and Schwartz, G. (2010). A refocused approach to writing
instruction: Incorporating a focus on genre into the writing process. Writing
and Pedagogy 2: 103-116. http://dx.doi.org/10.1558/wap.v2i1.103.
Newkirk, T. (2001). The revolt against realism: The attraction of fiction for young
writers. Elementary School Journal 101: 465–477. Retrieved on 1 March 2012
Nystrand, M. (2006) The social and historical context for writing research. In C.
MacArthur, S. Graham and J. Fitzgerald (eds.) Handbook of Writing Research
11–27. New York: Guildford.
Ofsted (2009) English at the Crossroads: An Evaluation of English in Primary and
Secondary Schools 2005/2008. London: Ofsted.
Olson, V. B. (1990). The revising process of sixth-grade writers with and without
feedback. Journal of Educational Research 84: 2–29.
Pantaleo, S. (2006) Readers and writers as intertexts: Exploring the intertextualities
in student writing. Australian Journal of Language and Literacy 29:
Pantaleo, S. (2010) Developing narrative competence through reading and writing
metafictive texts. Literacy Research and Instruction 49: 264–281. http://dx.doi.
Perry, N. (1998) Young children’s self-regulated learning and contexts that
support it. Journal of Educational Psychology 90: 715–729. http://dx.doi.
Peterson, S. S. (2012) An analysis of discourses of writing and writing instruction
in curricula across Canada. Curriculum Inquiry 42: 260–284. http://dx.doi.
Phinney, M. Y. (1998) Children “writing themselves”: A glimpse at the underbelly.
Language Arts 75: 19–27. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.ncte.
Pollington, M. F., Wilcox, B. and Morrison, T. G. (2001) Self-perception in
writing: The effects of writing workshop and traditional instruction on
intermediate grade students. Reading Psychology 22: 249–265. http://dx.doi.
Prater, D. L. and Bermudez, A. B. (1993) Using peer response groups with limited
English proficient writers. Bilingual Research Journal 17: 99–116. http://
Pritchard, R. J. and Honeycutt, R. L. (2006) The process approach to writing
instruction: Examining its effectiveness. In C. A. MacArther, S. Graham and
J. Fitzgerald (eds.) Handbook of Writing Research 275–290. New York:
Pritchard, R. J., and Honeycutt, R. L. (2007). Best practices in implementing a
process approach to teaching writing. In S. Graham, C. A. MacArthur and
J. Fitzgerald (eds.), Best Practices in Writing Instruction 28–49. New York:
Ranker, J. (2007a) Designing meaning with multiple media sources: A case study
of an eight-year-old student’s writing processes. Research in the Teaching of
English 41: 402–434. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.ncte.org/
Ranker, J. (2007b) Using comic books as read-alouds: Insights on reading
instruction from an English as a second language classroom. The Reading
Teacher 61: 296–305. http://dx.doi.org/10.1598/RT .61.4.2.
Ranker, J. (2009) Student appropriation of writing lessons through hybrid
composing practices: Direct, diffuse, and indirect use of teacher-offered
writing tools in an ESL classroom. Journal of Literacy Research 41: 393–431.
Ray, K. W. (2006) Exploring inquiry as a teaching stance in the writing workshop.
Language Arts 83: 238–247. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.ncte.
Richardson, P. (1991) Language as personal resources and social construct:
Competing views of literacy pedagogy in Australia. Educational Review 43:
Rose, D. (2009) Writing as linguistic mastery: The development of genre-based
literacy pedagogy. In R. Beard, D. Myhill, J. Riley and M. Nystrand (eds.)
Handbook of Writing Development 151–166. London: Sage.
Rowe, D. W., Fitch, J. M. and Bass, A. S. (2001) Power, identity, and instructional
stance in writers’ workshop. Language Arts 78: 426–434. Retrieved on 1 March
2012 from http://www.ncte.org/journals/la/issues/v78-5.
Rowe, D. W., Fitch, J. D. and Bass, A. S. (2003) Toy stories as opportunities for
imagination and reflection in writers’ workshop. Language Arts 80: 363–374.
Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.ncte.org/journals/la/issues/v80-5.
Ryan, M. and Kettle, M. (2012) Re-thinking context and reflexive mediation in the
teaching of writing. Australian Journal of Language and Literacy 35: 287–300.
Salahu-Dim, D., Persky, H. R. and Miller, J. (2008) The Nation’s Writing Report
Card: Writing 2007. Washington, D. C.: National Center for Education
Statistics, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education.
Sandmann, A. L. (2005) Friendship’s effect on the writing processes and products
of four fourth graders during their classroom writing workshop. Ohio Reading
Teacher 37: 59–68. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.questia.com/
Schneider, J. J. (2003) Contexts, genres, and imagination: An examination of
the idosyncratic writing performances of three elementary children within
multiple contexts of writing instruction. Research in the Teaching of English 37:
329–379. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://www.ncte.org/journals/rte/
Seawel, L., Smaldino, S. E., Steele, J. L. and Lewis, J. Y. (1994) A descriptive study
comparing computer-based word processing and handwriting on attitudes
and performance of third and fourth grade students involved in a program
based on a process approach to writing. Journal of Computing in Childhood
Education 5: 43–59. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://dl.acm.org/
citation.cfm?id=183707&CF ID=312021817&CFT OKEN=42129475.
Serna, C. (2009) Autores bilingues/bilingual authors: Writing within dual
cultural and linguistic repertoires. Education 130: 78–95. Retrieved
on 1 March 2012 from http://www.questia.com/read/1G1-207643765/
Sexton, M., Harris, K. R. and Graham, S. (1998) Self-regulated strategy
development and the writing process: Effects on essay writing and attributions.
Exceptional Children 64: 295–311. http://www.cec.sped.org/Publications/
Short, R. (2008) Through their eyes: Children’s perspectives on writing. Journal of
Reading Education 33(3): 15–20. Print.
Troia, G., Lin, S.-j. C., Cohen, S. and Monroe, B. W. (2011) A year in the writing
workshop: Linking writing instruction practices and teachers’ epistemologies
and beliefs about writing instruction. Elementary School Journal 112: 155–182.
Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/660688.
Turvey, A. (2007) Writing and teaching writing. Changing English 14: 145–159.
Ulichny, P. and Watson-Gegeo, K. A. (1989) Interactions and authority: The
dominant interpretive framework in writing conferences. Discourse Processes
12: 309–328. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/01638538909544733.
Van Leeuwen, C. A. and Gabriel, M. A. (2007) Beginning to write with word
processing: Integrating writing process and technology in a primary classroom.
The Reading Teacher 60: 420–429. http://dx.doi.org/10.1598/RT .60.5.2.
Vass, E., Littleton, K., Miell, D. and Jones, A. (2008) The discourse of collaborative
creative writing: Peer collaboration as a context for mutual inspiration. Thinking
Skills and Creativity 3: 192–202. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tsc.2008.09.001.
Vukelich, C. and Leverson, L. D. (1988) Text revisions by two young writers
following teacher/student conferences. Journal of Research in Childhood
Education 3: 46–54. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02568548809594786.
Wohlwend, K. E. (2009) Damsels in discourse: Girls consuming and producing
identity texts through Disney princess play. Reading Research Quarterly 44:
57–83. http://dx.doi.org/10.1598/RR Q.44.1.3.
Yan, G. (2005). A process genre model for teaching writing. English Teaching
Forum 43(3): 18–27. Retrieved on 1 March 2012 from http://americanenglish.